Is it time for yoshi to step down from ff14?

[magitekLuna]

The funny thing is unrealistically believing that the replacement would answer all of their prayers

no one say or think this what so ever.
its simple really if you can think that is.
we stay on yoshi and we have 10 more years of the SAME 1000% thing. more solo content , the same old and boring to death loop and on top of it GOOD msq that they cut short each time to jump to the next thing. like lets take the current msq. by 6.x they wasted all the interesting bosses and we left on one that is again an "evil being that is just misunderstood and really doing good thing for his people". like he can be an asian for all we care and nothing will change. then there the problem of the scions , we F disbanded stop use this characters for each story. get new one. hell at last helf the races if not more in the game are not even characters in the story . the scions by now are extremely bland and boring . they kill the story's they are part of.
now if we get some one new WE MAY GET NEW THING .

[Atelier-Bagur]

no one say or think this what so ever.
its simple really if you can think that is.
we stay on yoshi and we have 10 more years of the SAME 1000% thing. more solo content , the same old and boring to death loop and on top of it GOOD msq that they cut short each time to jump to the next thing. like lets take the current msq. by 6.x they wasted all the interesting bosses and we left on one that is again an "evil being that is just misunderstood and really doing good thing for his people". like he can be an asian for all we care and nothing will change. then there the problem of the scions , we F disbanded stop use this characters for each story. get new one. hell at last helf the races if not more in the game are not even characters in the story . the scions by now are extremely bland and boring . they kill the story's they are part of.
now if we get some one new WE MAY GET NEW THING .

Like I said.












The FUNEE thing is unrealistically believing that the replacement would answer all of their prayers.

[LianaThorne]

no one say or think this what so ever.
its simple really if you can think that is.
we stay on yoshi and we have 10 more years of the SAME 1000% thing. more solo content , the same old and boring to death loop and on top of it GOOD msq that they cut short each time to jump to the next thing. like lets take the current msq. by 6.x they wasted all the interesting bosses and we left on one that is again an "evil being that is just misunderstood and really doing good thing for his people". like he can be an asian for all we care and nothing will change. then there the problem of the scions , we F disbanded stop use this characters for each story. get new one. hell at last helf the races if not more in the game are not even characters in the story . the scions by now are extremely bland and boring . they kill the story's they are part of.
now if we get some one new WE MAY GET NEW THING .

It could also backfire completely and we could see the game start to be filled with NFTs or an even worse mog shop. Personally I'd rather have Yoshi than that.

[magitekLuna]

Like I said.












The FUNEE thing is unrealistically believing that the replacement would answer all of their prayers.

if you are not willing to read its ok just don't take part in the topic

[Atelier-Bagur]

if you are not willing to read its ok just don't take part in the topic

Ok how about this quote then. If it aint broke dont fix it?

We like to meme at the devs a lot for sure but asking for new blood when the current game is doing fine whether you like it or not is a stupid business move.


Its like firing somebody for being successful.


(Actually in hindsight, a lot of people make stupid business decisions anyway. But that still doesnt make it any less stupid)

[magitekLuna]

Ok how about this quote then. If it aint broke dont fix it?

We like to meme at the devs a lot for sure but asking for new blood when the current game is doing fine whether you like it or not is a stupid business move.


Its like firing somebody for being successful.


(Actually in hindsight, a lot of people make stupid business decisions anyway. But that still doesnt make it any less stupid)

how about fix it before it brakes as it to late when it is.
now at last being an argaman to the table like people here that like yoshi to stay did.

[LianaThorne]

how about fix it before it brakes as it to late when it is.
now at last being an argaman to the table like people here that like yoshi to stay did.

I think the things you're pointing out as broken are moreso related to personal taste than actually things that are breaking the game.

[DPZ2]

Every other games have flopped.

Prove that statement. Please. Use real numbers.

A game that cost 1 billion yen to make, and has 2 billion yen in sales, while another game with a similar cost had 12 billion yen in sales, is not a "flop", except to the hype machine. A game that cost 1 billion yen to make and has 800 million yen in sales is a "flop".

Any game introduced at the same time as the FF7 remake, or the next Nier game, is not a flop if it makes money.

I really get tired of people believing that FFXIV is the only money-making game that Square Enix produces. It is, by far, the most recognizable of the games produced, but it is not solely responsible for the company's profits.

The Digital Entertainment sector of Square Enix lists about 185 billion yen for net sales for FY2023/3 Q1 ‐ Q3 (reported on 3 February). The entire MMORPG section had just under 22% of that total in net sales.

[LianaThorne]

Prove that statement. Please. Use real numbers.

A game that cost 1 billion yen to make, and has 2 billion yen in sales, while another game with a similar cost had 12 billion yen in sales, is not a "flop", except to the hype machine. A game that cost 1 billion yen to make and has 800 million yen in sales is a "flop".

Any game introduced at the same time as the FF7 remake, or the next Nier game, is not a flop if it makes money.

I really get tired of people believing that FFXIV is the only money-making game that Square Enix produces. It is, by far, the most recognizable of the games produced, but it is not solely responsible for the company's profits.

The Digital Entertainment sector of Square Enix lists about 185 billion yen for net sales for FY2023/3 Q1 ‐ Q3 (reported on 3 February). The entire MMORPG section had just under 22% of that total in net sales.

I would think their mobile games are bringing in a pretty hefty chunk tbh.

[GTK0HLK]

People really have taken the notion that either the community is the reason why the game still exists..,(false, even if thirdparty additions died, the game would live on, as the original reason would still have people come and support it in gaps..,)

They've also taken the notion, that if something new shows up and it seems to replace what they want despite many logical alternatives as to why it was such, they'll bash it despite the fact its no less than decent.(like said in other threads with so called "Trolls", there is no story reason to have said content, or game reason atm.)

if switching out a person, who not only runs two ROLES, at the same time, who not only is in charge of managing a games development, and also has had blank checks in the past/is part of the board.
is a better option at all?
who would you replace them with, we all know they mess up at times, but people largely value someone who has a potential to listen beforehand(or if you wish to look at it that way, control) vs one who only does so when the company demands it, which is exactly what we would get I'd he was switched out.(we only need to look at other Companies who all had the same boat of Higher ups)

As I've said in many topics..,
We need to Push/Demand on the things that need fixing. Request QoL that improves the systems of the past and today. and Suggest additions that we want, that may not be as imperative or serious, but would overall enhance personal/subjective experiences.