the negatives of the new PLD and changes i'd like to see

[Melethron123]

Negatives:
- getting 3 attonements every combo feels way too spammy
- holy spirit animation and sound effect are lackluster
- goring blade feels completely "tacked on"
- rotation doesnt loop properly due to the number of GCDs

Changes I'd like
- atonement: each royal authority grants one stack (up to 3). atonement deals more damage and grants a stack of holy spirit (up to 3)
- holy spirit: changed into an off-GCD, requires stacks to be used
- goring blade: low-level version of atonement
- requiescat: upgraded version of fight or flight. buffs all dmg, grants confiteor ready, makes spells have the same recast as weaponskills

[Rithy255]

Suggested Changes
Atonement, Making it 1 charge seems boring, I'd want it to either be 2 charges of atonements which are slightly stronger or grant you a stack of Holy spirit, Atonement shouldn't break combos either.
OCGD holy spirit, No thanks I don't want another burst weave everything tank we got 2 already, its not really fun on tanks to weave constantly when you manage defensives/raidwides or if you need to move the boss holy spirit is a fun ability now you can use it way more flexible as sustain/ranged attack outside your burst windows I'll 100% agree change the animation though.
Goring Blade, I agree with your change making it a low level atonement (but not the single atonement lol), I'd also change it's animation as it would look kind of weird pressing it three times in a row.
Requiescat, Agreed I dislike pressing fof it's used for your magic burst mainly why does it need to be a separate button...

Overall Disagree with atonement and holy spirit changes, but I would want them to be changed either way just don't want another tank that spams OGCD's into bursts.