Quote Originally Posted by True-to-Caesar View Post
You do realize why Garrisons are considered a failure and heavily reduced player interactions ?
Those commodities aren’t needed. I’d understand a repair NPC but the rest is asking to repeat mistakes made by another studio.
I think you're conflating Garrisons with the WoD expansion as a whole.

It was the expansion that failed and not the Garrisons. Garrisons were moderately successful in that they gave players a reason to log in other than raiding. The expansion failed because that's all players were given.

That wouldn't be a problem here. Island Sanctuary (or housing) is just a tiny percentage of the things players can be doing. You could put all those things on Island Sanctuary (technology allowing) and players would still be going other places to do content.