I'm on the fence with Scholar. I love feeling powerful because it definitely gets the job done when you need healing but I do feel like it's a bit chaotic in terms of lore. Selene doesn't have a reason to exist. Seraph likewise has zero explanation about her origin. The ridiculously high tech animations feel silly coming from a class using a book and a quill pen. It's supposed to be a battle tactician but literally attacks enemies with a skill set nearly identical to to the other healers. One nuke, one dot like all the rest doesn't sound like a healer specializing in the "Art of War." I don't mind the colors and skills icons being varied tho. The hardest thing about Sage was starting a class at level 70 with every skill having a similar icon and animation. I actually like having skills that are distinct in name, icon, and animation. Scholar could benefit from being repackaged for sure. I've always thought that both WHM and SCH needed some help with the early animations. Medica and Succor did not age well just like most of the base kit they have.