Why Is Dynamis Dead

[RobynDaBank]

What, it was. You have a lot of people that liked it, and even within the forums you had people who enjoyed it. Even those who pointed out issues with it said that it just needs to be expanded further than the current base. At no point was it an "abject failure" like people were painting the whole expansion to be.

So...

Lmao yourself?

Read the context?

You know... It didn't fail?

You want content that failed? Remember that Diadem used to give armor with random stats? I wonder why we no longer have that

I mean come on, it's obvious. They didn't personally like it, and there was a bit of a stir about it on the forums... clearly means Islands were an abject failure.

[Deveryn]

I mean come on, it's obvious. They didn't personally like it, and there was a bit of a stir about it on the forums... clearly means Islands were an abject failure.

Yoshi not being into it doesn't mean much. He's busy and chooses to spend his little bit of game time on other things. A stir in the forums is a poor gauge as well. A lot of the negative commentary was from people misinforming themselves about what Island would be, like having Genshin or Stardew ported in. A lot of people actually enjoy it. They've taken feedback and they're working to improve it, so it's not a failure.

[Bsrking5]

It's only dead if you check it's state. Or alive. Just shake the box and hope for the best

[Midareyukki]

It's only dead if you check it's state. Or alive. Just shake the box and hope for the best

That's like... Reverse Schrodinger's Cat xD

"Is the Island dead or alive? The only way to figure out is by walking in there. The moment you do, however, it becomes alive, thus if it had ever died, you revived it. Like the world's most unlikely necromancer."

[LittleImp]

I don't personally know a single person who continues to interact with Island Sanctuary.

Heck, I know more people still actively participating in BLU content or Deep Dungeon than I do Island Sanctuary.

We can call it anecdotal all day, but it definitely looks like a failed system to me; I'll be surprised if it gets more than a few token updates that were already in the pipeline before it flopped.

[Atelier-Bagur]

I don't personally know a single person who continues to interact with Island Sanctuary.

Heck, I know more people still actively participating in BLU content or Deep Dungeon than I do Island Sanctuary.

We can call it anecdotal all day, but it definitely looks like a failed system to me; I'll be surprised if it gets more than a few token updates that were already in the pipeline before it flopped.

you didnt pay attention to their recent LL about it didnt you

[Midareyukki]

I don't personally know a single person who continues to interact with Island Sanctuary.

Heck, I know more people still actively participating in BLU content or Deep Dungeon than I do Island Sanctuary.

We can call it anecdotal all day, but it definitely looks like a failed system to me; I'll be surprised if it gets more than a few token updates that were already in the pipeline before it flopped.

You can try to meet other people, then. Because I know quite a fair bit of people who are actively invested in it and love spending time in there, as well as people who log in, go in there, press buttons and go out.

[Iscah]

you didnt pay attention to their recent LL about it didnt you

I saw the live letter slideshow, and Island Sanctuary's faults run deeper than some new types of materials and handicrafts (that you interact with in the same interface as the old ones) will fix.

The hints that animals might need management or they'll destroy stuff, if true, is more likely to make me write the whole thing off as a lost cause than to put in the expected work.

[Atelier-Bagur]

I saw the live letter slideshow, and Island Sanctuary's faults run deeper than some new types of materials and handicrafts (that you interact with in the same interface as the old ones) will fix.

The hints that animals might need management or they'll destroy stuff, if true, is more likely to make me write the whole thing off as a lost cause than to put in the expected work.

I'm just saying I wouldnt write it off that early when the team still have plans on updating that content.

[Tehmon]

Pretty sure they said 6.4 would have a bigger content update for Island Sanctuary. I wouldn't write the whole thing off until we can see what a more extensive patch to the Island Sanctuary entails. With most completely new things that are added to the game, I generally expect them to get bigger and better overtime.