SCH doesn't need a full rework and I wish people who don't play SCH or aren't SCH mains would stop asking for that. What SCH needs is more of its gutted DPS kit restored, not a "rework" in the vein of other jobs.

It's strange to say that this change would make Scholar "a LOT more accessible and competitive" when SCH is by far the best healer in the game and isn't struggling for competitiveness, especially when compared to it's barrier healer counterpart SGE, which has been struggling to compete with SCH at all since it released. SCH is the highest rDPS healer in Savage and is the best healer in DSR. Where is it struggling for competitiveness? Not saying this to be rude, but just wondering where the idea comes from that it's in any way needing to be more competitive compared to the other healers when it continues to be better than the other healers in practically every meaningful way.

Personally as a long time SCH main, SCH doesn't need "oh shit" buttons, especially when Recitation works in so many ways that it can quickly be used as that for a free crit Indom/Excog or can be combined with Emergency Tactics, Illum, Protraction and Dissipation to get more use as a flat curative HP heal. If anything, Dissipation is your "oh shit" button because of the full stack of Aetherflow it gives you and the buff to your GCD heals.

Now that SGE exists as well, we have to take into account at how much better Recitation Spreadlo can be than anything in SGE's kit for mitigative purposes and any buffs towards SCH's movement, which is likely what SE sees as the downside to Adlo being stronger than E. Diagnosis, just end up hurting SGE and make SCH that much stronger in comparison. (Though its honestly just as likely that there is no greater design philosophy behind it.)

Recitation is also an incredibly powerful, extremely flexible tool that SGE has no answer to. In fact I would say that outside of "ease of use", SGE really has nothing above SCH at all. I think SCH's healing kit still having a level of difficulty above the other healers is a good thing and it doesn't need to be made easier. It's good to have a healer that excels when it has a plan, and I'd say most complaints with SCH's healing kit are because people are looking at it from another healer job perspective (typically WHM, no offense) and instead not looking at SCH from the perspective of how SCH wants to heal. The "easier" we make SCH, the less of anything SGE has over it. That's not to say that things that feel awful shouldn't be fixed, but something to keep in mind in general when we take into account that Scholar is not only not struggling to keep up, it is doing laps around the other 3 healers with how powerful it is at healing and doing damage.

And honestly, no offense again but I'd say if SCH feels hard to play, especially in dungeons, it's likely an issue with a player's mastery of SCH moreso than any issue with SCH's kit. Recitation+Excog, popping down a Sacred Soil and then spamming Art of War handles almost any situation in pulls, especially considering you can always be targetting the tank and use your oGCDs as needed.