Quote Originally Posted by FireMage View Post
No, absolutely not. That is not actual balance, even ASSUMING full uptime MCH should be lower than every other Job on rDPS, sans SMN which it should be tied with.
Why? If a job is easy and therefore low DPS, it's not playable especially if it has no raid damage buffs. That's not balance or logical. That's stupid. The argument for "uptime" is irrelevant because that's a fight design issue as P8s has proven. We're no longer playing a game where "uptime" is a factor any more.