I fail to see how my suggestion is a discount GNB. I’m merely suggesting implementing a similar style of gauge for atonement while keeping the rest relatively the same. I do think I should have made it more clear that FoF should be 2 minutes and Req should be 1 since FoF is the raid buff in this scenario. I do like current PLD, but when you consider that sometimes my optimal rotation is to FoF 18 seconds before pull and I have to drop a GCD from my rotation to stay in raid buffs there is some awkwardness here that needs to be addressed and I think my suggestions do that.