I do not want any form of rewards and not even quest items!

I only wish we earned experience so we naturally level up doing new game+ from the beginning. My Dark knight is already level 90 and that is what I used to play through the whole game. It was a great experience using that class and being a tank, now I want to be able to play new game+ with a different class(Lancer/Dragoon) and earn xp naturally because you don't earn any form of xp at all doing new game+. Your expected to level the class up by killing monsters and doing dungeons and then do new game+ when reaching the minimum level of that quest. At the end of the day, the better choice for me was to make a complete new character and then choose lancer. That is why not earning xp doing new game+ becomes in a way pointless for me!

There is a reason why I mentioned a replay system and a actual new game+ system above! To stop people from exploiting the whole system would need to be revamped and then you can definitely see it as a possibility!