The main thing hurting Reaper atm is that it has the lowest rdps, along with one of the longest burst windows out of any melee dps. Doesn't help that it's rotation forces you to use burst to play it correctly due to circle and gluttony timers being clunky. Like how no matter how "correctly" you play it gluttony will drift over the course of a fight because of its tight timing. It's raid utility is a non factor when compared to other melees. And it's the only melee who's raid buff is punished for people being dead because of immortal sacrifice stacks. I don't understand how people say it's fine where it is while in, mnk, and drg are basically dominating the rdps scene while also having better utility.