Extreme Roulette would be good for game

[Deveryn]

If the group does end up with someone having issues, they can be encouraged to go back to Party Finder to join learning groups.

This right here would be the biggest reason this idea fails. I've joined plenty of PFs that are "duty complete". It's almost guaranteed you'll have at least one person who only just barely cleared once and still hasn't learned anything. Few are those actually honest enough to go back and run another learning party.

[Kaurhz]

yes, you are on a basis that everyone has time to be around a hunt trains when they happen, most people don't have that luxury.

I can assure you a hunt train will be just as frequent if not more frequent than the clear rates of doing extreme primal roulettes. Besides, you need to keep in mind that you equally get materia via just simply doing expert roulettes anyway, even if random.

The sum reward of 1 or 2 Dendro and Anthro clusters is an extremely pitiful reward. Arguably for the time invested on clearing and the rate of clearing you can multiply that by 5 if you like and it still wouldn't be worth it. That's 4-8K (Maybe 16K in a couple of weeks) Gil which is just awful considering the invested time. Players can simply do something else and then get far greater gains by selling items to just outright buy materia.

[TaleraRistain]

I'm not opposed to the idea if it doesn't take up tons of dev time but I question how popular it would be. And I agree with another poster that without any measures to prevent it, you'd probably see ilevel cheese to only get certain easier Extreme trials.

[Treesus]

As many others said, this would be dead on arrival. Youd either A. see people learning ARR fights and constantly cheesing it with iLVL tricks, or B. simply no one would do it. The rewards would have to be pretty massive to even get even a small amount of people to do it on a regular basis, and then that would only lower the pool of people doing basically every other roulette since the rewards needed to get people to actually DO it would mean people hitting their weekly caps much faster and then just not doing anything else. It would only cause issues to benefit a small pool of dutys that dont even get that much attention outside of people specifically looking TO do them, which can just as easily be done with friends/party finder.