Roe God choice

[Swampking]

Yes she original lived with pirates but prefers to fight with spears and swords. She decides to learn to spear fight in gurdaia and learns there and becomes a dragoon through quest. Plus she also learns dark knight later on.

[Illmaeran]

Yes she original lived with pirates but prefers to fight with spears and swords. She decides to learn to spear fight in gurdaia and learns there and becomes a dragoon through quest. Plus she also learns dark knight later on.

If her story began while living with pirates, Llymlaen may actually be the better choice of patron. There's nothing saying she can't pay respect to other gods as well, but it sounds like Llymlaen would be the god she grew up with unless the pirates were exceptionally vicious, which might make Rhalgr the better option.

Off topic; since boarding pikes were such a big thing in crew to crew combat for centuries, I never understood why Lancer didn't start in Limsa.