So, what now? Lotteries with 150+ bids until... when?

[Jojoya]

Why can't you just be happy with having 1?
A big part of the problem is people needing several houses..

No. The problem is SE created a system that does not provide enough supply to allow every player to have a house let alone every character.

I can go to almost any other MMO with housing and have no problem getting a dream plot for all of my characters in that game regardless of how many other player characters already own that dream plot. Some of those games even allow characters to own multiple housing locations.

There is no good reason for it to continue to be a problem here.

Stop blaming other players for the housing situation. Start blaming SE for their design choices.

[Gemina]

No. The problem is SE created a system that does not provide enough supply to allow every player to have a house let alone every character.

I can go to almost any other MMO with housing and have no problem getting a dream plot for all of my characters in that game regardless of how many other player characters already own that dream plot. Some of those games even allow characters to own multiple housing locations.

There is no good reason for it to continue to be a problem here.

Stop blaming other players for the housing situation. Start blaming SE for their design choices.

You are more than welcome to hop on over to any of those games. That is a neither here or there argument, and holds little if any bearing on the housing matter in FFXIV. You sound entitled when you make statements like this, and it is mentalities like this that go out there and try to own housing on each of their alts, and throw a hissy fit when they can't despite already owning a home on at least one of them. If you can't see the shear selfishness in this because this player knows full well that housing is a limited luxury in FFXIV, then I honestly don't know what else to tell you.

No one in FFXIV is entitled to a home, yet everyone thinks they are. Everyone also thinks they are entitled to a large or a medium at the least, which is why so many smalls were left with 0 bids when the entry periods ended. Those could have been easily picked up by anyone willing to settle on a small during earlier entry periods, and I'm quite sure a select few players realizing this swooped one up without a second thought.

tl;dr? I strongly suggest coming to terms with the fact that housing is finite. I don't say this to be a jerk, I say it for your own well-being for crying out loud. This is not the kind of thing to stress over. Seriously.

[Rolder50]

You are more than welcome to hop on over to any of those games. That is a neither here or there argument, and holds little if any bearing on the housing matter in FFXIV. You sound entitled when you make statements like this, and it is mentalities like this that go out there and try to own housing on each of their alts, and throw a hissy fit when they can't despite already owning a home on at least one of them. If you can't see the shear selfishness in this because this player knows full well that housing is a limited luxury in FFXIV, then I honestly don't know what else to tell you.

No one in FFXIV is entitled to a home, yet everyone thinks they are. Everyone also thinks they are entitled to a large or a medium at the least, which is why so many smalls were left with 0 bids when the entry periods ended. Those could have been easily picked up by anyone willing to settle on a small during earlier entry periods, and I'm quite sure a select few players realizing this swooped one up without a second thought.

tl;dr? I strongly suggest coming to terms with the fact that housing is finite. I don't say this to be a jerk, I say it for your own well-being for crying out loud. This is not the kind of thing to stress over. Seriously.

Not often I see rants this condescending on here. Comparing your product of choice to the competition in the same field is very normal and should be encouraged, as maybe SE will see and actually do something about it. Having an entire gameplay system that whole swathes of the community can't directly interact with is just poor design, full stop.

[Arzalis]

You are more than welcome to hop on over to any of those games. That is a neither here or there argument, and holds little if any bearing on the housing matter in FFXIV. You sound entitled when you make statements like this, and it is mentalities like this that go out there and try to own housing on each of their alts, and throw a hissy fit when they can't despite already owning a home on at least one of them. If you can't see the shear selfishness in this because this player knows full well that housing is a limited luxury in FFXIV, then I honestly don't know what else to tell you.

No one in FFXIV is entitled to a home, yet everyone thinks they are. Everyone also thinks they are entitled to a large or a medium at the least, which is why so many smalls were left with 0 bids when the entry periods ended. Those could have been easily picked up by anyone willing to settle on a small during earlier entry periods, and I'm quite sure a select few players realizing this swooped one up without a second thought.

tl;dr? I strongly suggest coming to terms with the fact that housing is finite. I don't say this to be a jerk, I say it for your own well-being for crying out loud. This is not the kind of thing to stress over. Seriously.

They actually advertise it as one of the major features of the game and you certainly aren't paying any less if you don't have one.

Not only that, but comparing how other games do their systems is good and healthy. It's especially pertinent when the devs keep saying things like "It's not possible to do x!" when you see half a dozen other comparable games do that very thing. That means it's not impossible, it means they just don't want to for some reason and they aren't telling us why.

Realistically, it's just something they don't focus on because the devs are seriously out of touch with what the playerbase wants prioritized on a lot of issues. That's been fairly obvious for a few years now, mostly with things like Hrothgar and Viera, but it's definitely started to leak over into other aspects of the game. Though I guess things like housing have actually been an issue for like 5-6 years at this point, so maybe it's the other way around.

IMO, there's a bit of arrogance with FFXIV devs that didn't used to exist. If you watch an older live letter compared to one nowadays, it's night and day how much more ego is involved in everything.

[Jojoya]

No one in FFXIV is entitled to a home, yet everyone thinks they are. Everyone also thinks they are entitled to a large or a medium at the least, which is why so many smalls were left with 0 bids when the entry periods ended. Those could have been easily picked up by anyone willing to settle on a small during earlier entry periods, and I'm quite sure a select few players realizing this swooped one up without a second thought.

What other reward in the game is so limited in quantity that a player might never be able to get it despite putting in large amounts of time and effort? Doesn't it seem strange to you that "entitlement" is only a problem in this one specific area when SE is so accommodating in all the rest?

You know why there were so many small houses left with 0 entries in the earlier lottery periods? It's because they were in the FC wards. If you're trying to get a personal house, you can't bid on the ones in the FC wards. The personal wards filled up fast once we got past the 0 bug. The only houses left were those being vacated by owners who relocated to other plots.

MMOs do not thrive when popular content is limited to access by the lucky few. That's why you almost never see such systems implemented outside of PvP, with those limitations at least gated by skill-based competition.

IMO, there's a bit of arrogance with FFXIV devs that didn't used to exist. If you watch an older live letter compared to one nowadays, it's night and day how much more ego is involved in everything.

I don't think that's true. The differences are more from improvements in production of the Live Letter than any negative change on the part of YoshiP and Foxclon. They're probably more relaxed because they no longer need to worry about whether the game is going to still end up dying after all the work they put in to save it.

If there is a problem, it's upper management juggling things behind the scenes to move FFXIV resources to their other IPs. That sort of thing is normal in most companies running multiple projects but they have to be careful they don't drain the project that's making the others possible or everything can fall apart.

[Arzalis]

What other reward in the game is so limited in quantity that a player might never be able to get it despite putting in large amounts of time and effort? Doesn't it seem strange to you that "entitlement" is only a problem in this one specific area when SE is so accommodating in all the rest?

You know why there were so many small houses left with 0 entries in the earlier lottery periods? It's because they were in the FC wards. If you're trying to get a personal house, you can't bid on the ones in the FC wards. The personal wards filled up fast once we got past the 0 bug. The only houses left were those being vacated by owners who relocated to other plots.

MMOs do not thrive when popular content is limited to access by the lucky few. That's why you almost never see such systems implemented outside of PvP, with those limitations at least gated by skill-based competition.


I don't think that's true. The differences are more from improvements in production of the Live Letter than any negative change on the part of YoshiP and Foxclon. They're probably more relaxed because they no longer need to worry about whether the game is going to still end up dying after all the work they put in to save it.

If there is a problem, it's upper management juggling things behind the scenes to move FFXIV resources to their other IPs. That sort of thing is normal in most companies running multiple projects but they have to be careful they don't drain the project that's making the others possible or everything can fall apart.

Not sure I agree. There was a lot more humility and humbleness because they seemed genuinely thankful folks were playing the game after the mess that was 1.0 and that sentiment lasted a very long time. It's what fostered a large part of all the goodwill the game got. That sort of thing doesn't really happen nowadays, especially relevant with how many issues the game seems to have with every patch lately. It's not that they have bad attitudes or anything, far from it, it's just that they act a lot differently now.

If anything, I'd say they seem less relaxed and more stuffy compared to earlier LLs.

[Sairys]

You are more than welcome to hop on over to any of those games. That is a neither here or there argument, and holds little if any bearing on the housing matter in FFXIV. You sound entitled when you make statements like this, and it is mentalities like this that go out there and try to own housing on each of their alts, and throw a hissy fit when they can't despite already owning a home on at least one of them. If you can't see the shear selfishness in this because this player knows full well that housing is a limited luxury in FFXIV, then I honestly don't know what else to tell you.

No one in FFXIV is entitled to a home, yet everyone thinks they are. Everyone also thinks they are entitled to a large or a medium at the least, which is why so many smalls were left with 0 bids when the entry periods ended. Those could have been easily picked up by anyone willing to settle on a small during earlier entry periods, and I'm quite sure a select few players realizing this swooped one up without a second thought.

tl;dr? I strongly suggest coming to terms with the fact that housing is finite. I don't say this to be a jerk, I say it for your own well-being for crying out loud. This is not the kind of thing to stress over. Seriously.

This post reads like those from people who have a house or, at least, FC house privileges who are desperately arguing to maintain the status quo because it makes them feel artificially special.

Everyone pays the same sub to access the game, those who have housing have access to a feature not everyone can have due to those limits. It is not selfish to want to access a feature you are, in effect, paying for. What is selfish is the many posts from those with houses in favour of the system as is because, realistically, the costs of these servers are paid for by our subs so those without are paying for something those with have, no matter how small a part of our sub that is.

The mentality that everyone else should just "come to terms with the fact" that those who have houses "got theirs" is incredibly toxic. Realistically, players who have houses, personal or fc, that actually believe this rhetoric should demolish them because if you're happy to accept that not everyone can have one then you should be fine without yours.

edit: Obviously, there are people with housing that actually empathise with those who don't and want to see the system change which this is not directed at. Only those who want to gatekeep housing

[Stroban]

It’s a question of money for me. I think maybe the developers would like to offer more houses for the players but there’s square enix that has to say no because it takes more means to do that. That is why many players are so frustrated for economic reasons.