Time to close the thread perhaps since it has spiralled from what it was originally about?

Regarding the topic; and this is just IMO; Alphie (my bro), Allie (my bro:a) and Urianger is the top-tier scions.

Y'shtola is fine, but thr shortcomings of her character are mostly saved by her comedic sass.
Remove the sass and what is there to like about her, really?

Thancred, Krile and G'raha Tia (he is great as the exarch after that not so much) are, meh. They are absolutely bottom tier.
I would not be mad if they left the scions/died or otherwise disappeared from the story.

My 5cents.