Enough cheap talking, we need to discuss what really matters here, alright? So, I did a study on this subject. Here are my assumptions:
  • Minfilia: Sings perfectly average, just like her character;
  • Y'shtola: Sings pretty well, but only agrees to sing after she's drunk;
  • Thancred: Doesn't even sing that well, but his energy carries the party;
  • Alphinald: The glass breaker;
  • Alisaie: Average to bad, didn't even want to be in this place;
  • Lyse: Sings awful, but doesn't realize she's hurting the party and keeps singing;
  • Papalymo: Disaster duo with Lyse;
  • Krile: Sings pretty well. I don't have any jokes for this character;
  • Urianger: Sings unexpectedly well, but only sings old songs that no one knows;
  • G'raha Tia: Teams up with Y'shotla after both are drunk;
  • Ryne: Too embarassed to sing, but it's the best singer by far;
  • Cid: Doesn't sing, just watches from afar and gets drunk.

This is my take. Any thoughts?