People misunderstanding of MCH and what it actually needs

[Reylap]

Consistency? That's everyone's job.

IDK what are you trying to imply here other than the fact that everyone just needs to get good except that situation is not realistic practically speaking. Theres a reason why people are divided over certain parses level of xxth percentile. Its precisely because everyone have a different skill level that they need to get good at. MCH by its nature currently its a low floor low ceiling class (i.e. almost braindead) that you can play decently well and do a good amout of damage enough to clear anything. To put it very bluntly, DNC/BRD with 95th percently is unlikely not able to carry other DPS on the 50th below percentile because their kit is tied to the performance of that other DPS. Switching to MCH gives you more chance to clear because a MCH with 95th percentile is going to do way more compared to the other combination.

Flexiblity? If you don't have a MCH, it doesn't mean the door is completely closed to you. Someone else can adjust their rotation, even rigid rotation.

I never stated that the door is completely closed. I'm merely pointing out the comparison to BRD and DNC that people thinks the DPS problem is solved just because they change to this 2 jobs. No they dont. And MCH has an edge when it comes down to doing DPS compared to the other 2 which is the point Im already making as the highest ADPS compared to the 2

DNC > You're at the mercy of dance partner. Yes you can change DP but you're still not capable of adding additional burst that is in your command because flourish is the only additional burst and you are already bursting every single feather fan and saber dance that you have in CD. the change to DP also comes to the problem of "optimal" DP meaning that if you have a comp currently with NIN, DNC, RDM, and BLM for example, if your NIN is dead, BLM and RDM are not good DP. You don't change technical timing just to ensure you technical when the weakness is gone on Nin. you still do it on 120s cd.
BRD > Same problem as above just less focus on one person.

There is 1 ranged spot to compete for, melee and caster can compete for a second spot.
Sure, you can go 2 phys ranged and clear the content, but that's willingly shooting yourself in the foot.

Phy Range problem not MCH problems. Unless you change MCH to be more punishing like BLM you're not going to have this combination. And that is SE job iteration atm. Curse it all you want but I have made my point previously about this and this is the current iteration they belive to be complete