Finally a good Topic for a General Discussion.. i found this a while ago and found it very interesting:

Just to throw this out there (it may be blatantly obvious or i may be way off...) but the relation of attributes to crafting was given to us not long ago. It went like this:

Class Main Hand Tool Off Hand Tool
Carpenter VIT DEX
Blacksmith STR MND
Armorer VIT STR
Goldsmith DEX INT
Leatherworker VIT INT
Weaver DEX MND
Alchemist INT PIE
Culinarian MND PIE

Now, perhaps the Craft vs MagCraft issue boils down to non-Mag vs Mag attributes respectively. This would be to say, anything using STR, DEX, or VIT would be affected by Craftsmanship and anything using INT, MND, or PIE would be affected by MagCraftsmanship. So Carpenters would benefit from Craft+ gear, whereas Alchemists would benefit from MagCraft+ gear. This would also be to say that Goldsmiths would benefit from Craft+ gear when using their main hand and MagCraft+ gear when using their off hand (according to this). What say you to this?