I have not seen one post on this entire thread that actually looks at the overall goals for the implementation of the auto-attack. It is very clear that the launch of FFXIV did not go so well. Poll results show that over 85% voted yes when asked "Would you welcome changes to FINAL FANTASY XIV that would drastically alter the rules already set in Eorzea?" We, voted yes on that so everyone needs to stop crying now that they are doing something about it. The fact of the matter is, is that the auto-attack will do wonders to FFXIV's combat system. Currently using your basic attack does nothing to actually add skill or tactic into combat (except promote stamina management). The only reason for having a basic attack is to generate TP to use your useful skills. By automating this process, they are taking focus away from basic attack spamming and putting the focus onto useful abilities that promote skill and tactics in team play. People need to be looking at the real focus of this implementation to see that it is truly necessary. Yes, it is true that removing the current system will make combat less involving at low ranks. However, SE is not focusing on making combat exciting for rank 1's. The truth is that the implementation of auto-attack will do wonders for high rank play, making it much more skillful. That is why everyone one of us plays this game. We play to rank up, and as we rank up, there needs to be more of a challenge to keep the gameplay interesting. When you have 30 different abilities at rank 50, you should not be spamming one of them for 80% of the fight. By implementing the auto-attack, they are implementing SKILL and TACTICS into FFXIV at high rank play. I don't see how anyone can argue against that.