I know this might just be me being nostalgic af but man, I miss Pharos Sirius as it launched in 2.1.
I remember timing out on it once or twice during the first few days. People really had to pay attention, and that's honestly what it's always felt like it was about: paying attention. Even nowadays, the last boss of Haukke HM still wipes groups here and there cause people have this level of automaticity ingrained in them which just... goes off with little regard to mechanics.

...All that said, I am pretty torn on this topic. On one hand, I absolutely see people's point when they say they don't want to be spending upwards of 30-40 minutes in a dungeon roulette, something which grants daily rewards. I wouldn't want that either. On the other hand, most dungeons are a walk in the park, and some level of engagement would be nice...

Idk. I'm torn.