Page 18 of 32 FirstFirst ... 8 16 17 18 19 20 28 ... LastLast
Results 171 to 180 of 347

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Player
    YukiB's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2022
    Posts
    165
    Character
    Yuki Bajhiri
    World
    Lamia
    Main Class
    Samurai Lv 90
    Just made a forum account to add my dissent to the removal of Hissatsu: Kaiten, for all the many reasons stated in this thread:
    • Loss of class fantasy (!!!)
    • Loss of aesthetically pleasing animation and sound
    • Loss of (mildly) engaging gauge management
    • Loss of oGCD variety

    As petty as it is, this proposed change has killed my motivation to play the game. I was starting to really enjoy SAM and had been gearing mine up. It was my favorite DPS this expansion. But what I don't enjoy is SAM's gameplay prior to 52. Kaiten's satisfying flourish, the way it flows into the iaijutsu animation, and the class fantasy of focusing energy into our powerful attacks, defines the job in my eyes. Shinten is boring in comparison. I don't want to play SAM without Kaiten. And if I don't want to play my favorite DPS, how do I justify playing the others?

    I'll almost certainly unsub until 6.2 or 6.3 if Hissatsu: Kaiten is removed.

    Technically off-topic, but I can't say I'm thrilled about the guaranteed crit changes either due to job synergy concerns. A much better idea to address crit variance is to make our larger attacks multiple hits where appropriate. Midare Setsugekka, Kaeshi Setsugekka, and Hissatsu: Senei are perfect candidates to be turned into 2-hit attacks. Shoha can be turned into 5 hits if you're desperate. Ogi Namikiri and Kaeshi Namikiri are problematic, but you can make those two alone guaranteed crits if you want.
    (7)

  2. #2
    Player
    Leemon's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2022
    Posts
    27
    Character
    Leemon Orlandue
    World
    Kujata
    Main Class
    Fisher Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by YukiB View Post

    As petty as it is, this proposed change has killed my motivation to play the game... And if I don't want to play my favorite DPS, how do I justify playing the others?

    I'll almost certainly unsub until 6.2 or 6.3 if Hissatsu: Kaiten is removed
    Nothing's petty about it and hey, more power to you. If they can say 'Oh your favourite job got gutted? Tough luck, play another job', what's stopping us to say 'Oh my favourite job got gutted? Time to stop playing this game'

    You're not alone here, we're all here because we love SAM and the fun of playing it, not just because we have to play a job or any job in this game.

    They say the harshest thing you can do to a comedian is to not laugh at their joke. The harshest thing you can do towards this change is to not play this game when the change is applied (which let's be honest, it's already set in stone for now)
    (4)

  3. #3
    Player
    Duskane's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2018
    Location
    isnt it messed up that goblet is a housing area and not a tiny goblin
    Posts
    4,205
    Character
    Dusk Himmel
    World
    Ravana
    Main Class
    Viper Lv 100
    Eukrasia is a GCD its only vaguely similar to DRK arts with its effect change,
    but its no where near as spammable nor does it cost any resources.

    also gurren is cool don't merge it with senei

    shoha should just turn into an AOE
    merge Tsubame and Iajutsu
    third eye might aswell be deleted
    and i don't think Yaten is necessary
    (0)

  4. #4
    Player
    forsakee's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2021
    Posts
    141
    Character
    Garnet Stormborn
    World
    Excalibur
    Main Class
    Reaper Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by Duskane View Post
    Eukrasia is a GCD its only vaguely similar to DRK arts with its effect change,
    but its no where near as spammable nor does it cost any resources.

    also gurren is cool don't merge it with senei

    shoha should just turn into an AOE
    merge Tsubame and Iajutsu
    third eye might aswell be deleted
    and i don't think Yaten is necessary
    too much gutting/simplifying I hate your idea as much as devs idea, leave third eye alone already made it easier to use.
    (0)

  5. #5
    Player
    Hyuinn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2022
    Posts
    11
    Character
    Eric Hyuinn
    World
    Behemoth
    Main Class
    Gunbreaker Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by Duskane View Post
    Eukrasia is a GCD its only vaguely similar to DRK arts with its effect change,
    but its no where near as spammable nor does it cost any resources.

    also gurren is cool don't merge it with senei

    shoha should just turn into an AOE
    merge Tsubame and Iajutsu
    third eye might aswell be deleted
    and i don't think Yaten is necessary
    I'm going to address point by point:
    - shoha merge is nice, I don't get why paladin spirit's within / expiacion got this treatment and shoha didn't
    - merging tsubame and iaijutsu isn't nice, learning how to not drift tsubame requires a lot of discipline which for me is core to what the samurai fantasy is, not a mindless brute swinging it's sword, and the same can be said about kaiten (requires some decision making alongside shinten so you have enough for your burst without overcapping it)
    - if you're not using third eye then you're not ready to reach the skill ceiling of the job. it mitigates damage and gives you kenki back so you can do even more damage which is your goal by the end of the day. be smart and be rewarded.
    - every melee needs movement options, a gtfo button is more than appreciated so you don't have to disengage too early from the target.

    EDIT: forgot some points so...
    - yeah don't merge guren with senei, I actually like senei's animation a lot more
    - eukrasia cost one resource, which is time, the most important one because it's tied to the gcd. dark arts and kaiten don't make you lose a cast of something because of it.
    (0)
    Last edited by Hyuinn; 04-05-2022 at 01:52 PM.

  6. #6
    Player
    LeonKeyh's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2020
    Location
    Gridania
    Posts
    655
    Character
    Leon Keyh
    World
    Cactuar
    Main Class
    Dragoon Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by Hyuinn View Post
    I'm going to address point by point:
    [...]
    - merging tsubame and iaijutsu isn't nice, learning how to not drift tsubame requires a lot of discipline which for me is core to what the samurai fantasy is, not a mindless brute swinging it's sword, and the same can be said about kaiten (requires some decision making alongside shinten so you have enough for your burst without overcapping it)
    - if you're not using third eye then you're not ready to reach the skill ceiling of the job. it mitigates damage and gives you kenki back so you can do even more damage which is your goal by the end of the day. be smart and be rewarded.
    [...]
    I'm definitely missing something with your point on drift and Tsubame that makes you think that combining them wouldn't be nice. Doesn't Tsubame reset if you use any other GCD after your Iaijustu? Not sure I understand why you would need them to be separate buttons. Do you mean that it's more difficult to hit the other button after Iaijutsu, that there is skill expression in the fact that you have to hit 2 buttons instead of just slamming 1 until both go off?

    IMO, Third Eye is bad design right now. It essentially gives you extra DPS if you take damage (I realize it's a minuscule amount, but it's still an overall bad design) which means you're rewarded for getting hit. You shouldn't be rewarding people for taking damage, and anything that increases damage is more likely to just be used "on cooldown" rather than being used at the "best" time. I know there are caveats with Third Eye in particular (and I know that most SAMs are using it for raid wides, not to stand in telegraphed/avoidable AEs), and the main effect is good for SAM, but I don't think it should give Kenki unless it's similar to TBN where it uses it and then gives it back if you "use it correctly." It should never be a DPS gain to get hit by something. That's just my opinion though, one that I'm sure SAM mains will hate me for saying.
    (0)

  7. #7
    Player
    RezPls's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2016
    Posts
    49
    Character
    Rez Pls
    World
    Gilgamesh
    Main Class
    Arcanist Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by LeonKeyh View Post
    If there were an instance of raidwide damage, I'd simply avoid it.
    I couldn't agree more, taking damage is a sign of weakness and puts you at risk of death; why should we reward players for doing this? Also how am I even supposed to know when to hit "Third Eye"??? The duration is so short and there's no way I could possibly know when an instance of unavoidable damage is coming out. It's extremely unfair and unfun to create skill gaps in a game via this unnecessary button bloat that Yoshida seems to have a hardon for.
    (1)

  8. #8
    Player Ransu's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    Leaving my SAM in Kugane
    Posts
    2,948
    Character
    Raansu Omiyari
    World
    Gilgamesh
    Main Class
    Samurai Lv 100
    Quote Originally Posted by RezPls View Post
    I couldn't agree more, taking damage is a sign of weakness and puts you at risk of death; why should we reward players for doing this? Also how am I even supposed to know when to hit "Third Eye"??? The duration is so short and there's no way I could possibly know when an instance of unavoidable damage is coming out. It's extremely unfair and unfun to create skill gaps in a game via this unnecessary button bloat that Yoshida seems to have a hardon for.
    I hope this is sarcasm...
    (0)

  9. #9
    Player
    Hyuinn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2022
    Posts
    11
    Character
    Eric Hyuinn
    World
    Behemoth
    Main Class
    Gunbreaker Lv 90
    Quote Originally Posted by LeonKeyh View Post
    I'm definitely missing something with your point on drift and Tsubame that makes you think that combining them wouldn't be nice. Doesn't Tsubame reset if you use any other GCD after your Iaijustu? Not sure I understand why you would need them to be separate buttons. Do you mean that it's more difficult to hit the other button after Iaijutsu, that there is skill expression in the fact that you have to hit 2 buttons instead of just slamming 1 until both go off?

    IMO, Third Eye is bad design right now. It essentially gives you extra DPS if you take damage (I realize it's a minuscule amount, but it's still an overall bad design) which means you're rewarded for getting hit. You shouldn't be rewarding people for taking damage, and anything that increases damage is more likely to just be used "on cooldown" rather than being used at the "best" time. I know there are caveats with Third Eye in particular (and I know that most SAMs are using it for raid wides, not to stand in telegraphed/avoidable AEs), and the main effect is good for SAM, but I don't think it should give Kenki unless it's similar to TBN where it uses it and then gives it back if you "use it correctly." It should never be a DPS gain to get hit by something. That's just my opinion though, one that I'm sure SAM mains will hate me for saying.
    You need to keep track of Tsubame Gaeshi cooldown to know when to Midare. If they're the same button you can't do that, hence why you need them separate. It's not about being easier or harder to press. using midare in the wrong time means you either have to wait 5 seconds or so before doing Kaeshi without using any other weaponskills or doing said weaponskill and drifting Tsubame for 8 to 12 seconds assuming you are not using Higanbana (which you probably are since both of them are 60s cooldown, so you will also mess up that timing).

    Third Eye isn't supposed to be rewarding for getting hit. It rewards you for parrying, since you will get hit regardless in content. If you're stepping in AoEs to get Eye proc, you're doing it wrong, but that being said you could definitely not dodge something to keep uptime and use Third Eye to help your healer and get extra gauge which is still smart play if handled right.

    Quote Originally Posted by RezPls View Post
    I couldn't agree more, taking damage is a sign of weakness and puts you at risk of death; why should we reward players for doing this? Also how am I even supposed to know when to hit "Third Eye"??? The duration is so short and there's no way I could possibly know when an instance of unavoidable damage is coming out. It's extremely unfair and unfun to create skill gaps in a game via this unnecessary button bloat that Yoshida seems to have a hardon for.
    Do the fight multiple times and read the cast bar so you'll know when to use Third Eye. After a few wipes you'll definitely know what's an AoE from the boss and what's not, what's dodgeable and what isn't. If the duration was longer people wouldn't have to learn how/when to use it and just "press on cooldown" as you guys are making it out to be. Sometimes you can't use Third Eye because you'll be weaving other stuff, so it falls onto you, the samurai, to decide if you're going to delay your Iaijustu a bit so you can parry and get extra gauge, or if you're gonna try to do it anyways regardless of how tight the execution would be.
    (0)

  10. #10
    Player
    LeonKeyh's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2020
    Location
    Gridania
    Posts
    655
    Character
    Leon Keyh
    World
    Cactuar
    Main Class
    Dragoon Lv 90
    The problem is that there are just so many other ways to get rid of button bloat. Kaiten was _FUN_ to press, because you know that you're buffing that big hit that is coming, you watch your character twirl its sword. It was fun, regardless of whether it was "only there to punish you if you miscounted kenki."

    They could have instead (I'm not suggesting they actually do any of these, I'm just listing "better", IMO, ways of cleaning it up):

    Combine Tsubame-gaeshi and Iajutsu so you just press Iajutsu again to repeat
    Combine Shoha and Shoha II into a single attack that does X damage to target + AE fall off damage
    Combine Guren and Senei into a single attack that does X damage to target + AE fall off damage
    Combine Shinten and Kyuten into a single attack that does X damage to target + AE fall off damage
    Combine Gyoten and Yaten into a single ability that takes you to an enemy/friendly (I'm not sure how often these are really used in more difficult content though, admittedly)

    Hell, even changing the 3/3/2 combos to 3/2/2 would have felt better than this change.
    (1)

Page 18 of 32 FirstFirst ... 8 16 17 18 19 20 28 ... LastLast