Quote Originally Posted by Saraide View Post
Personalized loot sounds great imo. What makes you against alliance raid gear being on the same ilevel as BiS gear?
BiS should be from the hardest content imo, Alliance Raids is more casual content I mean you can basically just spam 1 and get carried.
You can't really do that in Savage.
I think the difficulty of Savage isn't on some elitist ultra level or anything but it's clearly harder than Alliance Raids and imo it's harder than most Extremes.

Quote Originally Posted by Vahlnir View Post
Doesn't really help PUGs either. lol But yeah, not a good idea. The personal loot system is absolutely terrible.
Why would it be terrible.
In WoW and Diablo 3 for example there's RNG on top of RNG, in FFXIV the gear is what it is I am not saying that the stats should be randomized or whatever.

I don't really understand why you'd be against guaranteed loot for clearing the content.
If you're in a static it'd also just mean that everyone in the group gets gear so if anything it'd help statics too.
The loot would still appear like it does now in my example, just that everyone gets to pick and get it guaranteed instead of roll against each other so I fail to see why it'd hurt statics.