Speaking of items that look completely identical and suffer from this system for no reason, wanna see something comical?
These are, in order, Makai Vanbreaker's Quartertights(GNB), Makai Harrower's Quartertights(RPR), Makai Manhandler's Quartertights(MNK+SAM), Makai Markswoman's Quartertights(Phys Ranged), Makai Priestess's Skirt(Caster), and Makai Moon Guide's Quartertights(Healer).
Ignoring that the Caster one is randomly called a "skirt" despite still being shorts(seriously, what's up with that? I noticed this while writing this up...),
THEY ALL LOOK EXACTLY THE SAME, it's peak frustration with this system that I have to carry 6 identical copies of an item, two of which are exclusively class locked, not even by role...
As a side note, Makai Moon Guide also includes the Makai Moon Guide's Circlet, which is the sole Spider Lily headpiece in the entire game, it would be amazing on Reaper, but it is Healer-locked.