For me it's something like:

Thancred - 4.5 stars
Estinien - 5 stars
Alisaie - 5 stars
Alphinaud - 3 stars
G'raha Tia - 2 stars
Krile - 1 star
Tataru - 2 stars
Minfilia - 1 star
Ryne - 3 stars
Y'shtola - 3 stars
Urianger - 4 stars

I like'em mostly, but they could all stand to become actual characters again rather than scriptwriter mouthpieces/WoL praise machines.