Quote Originally Posted by CrownySuccubus View Post
Umm, but he already knew. He asked the Watcher what would happened to the reflections and the Watcher confirms that they would also be destroyed. Then, just before they leave the moon, the Scions have already made up their minds that their primary focus is going to be on stopping the Final Days than running from it. Thancred having a temper tantrum because the First would be abandon would be redundant to what we'd already established and, furthermore, would have been absolutely pointless because there's no way for anyone except the Ascians and the WOL to travel between the worlds anyway.



Minfilia chose to sacrifice herself to save the first. Krile flat out says multiple times that she chose to be used on the occasions Hydaelyn did it.

Again, I don't like Hydaelyn in EW either, but you guys are reaching too hard to find things to be angry about.



Both out of unfortunate necessity, though. I'm not against the fact that you had to fight and kill the elder primals. I would have been against yet another "Only Mankind is the true arbiter of morality and destiny!" message.



I mean, Zodiark was a skin suit for Fandaniel the one time you see him, soooo....
No one is reaching. We went from almost half of the scions being suspicious of Hydaelyn to none at all in EW. That is a clear in favor of her, especially since you’d think if they’re already suspicious of her, being told about how she’s lied and kept secrets should make it even worse, but it doesn’t. Also, your argument is because they were pressed for time and worried about the final days? Funny how they didn’t seem that pressed when they were playing dress-up with rabbits, having lunch and coffee dates etc. Convenient.

I think the most jarring piece though is, we have Alphinaud have a huge speech in ShB that should, make him completely hate and dislike Hydaelyn.

Alphinaud once said in Shadowbringers that living in a Rejoined world would be against his beliefs, saying, "But what value is there in surviving when all our history, all our struggles will be erased? I cannot conscience such an act."

Yet he not once remarks upon this towards Hydaelyn, who literally did just that? Yeah no, very clear bias and there isn’t a reach going on.