What's the point with that quite lackluster story in Endwalker?

[KizuyaKatogami]

I wonder how you'd feel if Elidibus and Venat switched roles, but everything else was the same. So Elidibus caused the sundering, Venat was the heart of Zodiark.

You seem to be real hung on on Venat being a woman. Like.. You just can't let that one thing go, it comes across are rather crass honestly.

Plus, if the Ascians succeeded, all currently living souls lose their agency, through no actions of their own.

Ah yes, pleading misogyny when someone disagrees with a video game character. Next up on how low and can the lore community go.

[Vahlnir]

Ah yes, pleading misogyny when someone disagrees with a video game character. Next up on how low and can the lore community go.

Emet-Selch was right all along it seems.

[SentioftheHoukai]

Emet-Selch was right all along it seems.

Always has been.

Hey, we do not diss Jedi: Fallen Order!

Low hanging fruit, hey! Can I have some? ;3

It's unfortunate you feel she does that for you. Many people love Y'shtola and finds she makes the scenes she's in very enjoyable. All of those takes on both sides are opinions. She doesn't objectively "make" or "ruin" anything.

Hey, now. I don't see any "in my opinions" in here. Also, "many people?" who are these many people you speak of? We need names, details. Every last one. ;3

[Striker44]

Hey, now. I don't see any "in my opinions" in here. Also, "many people?" who are these many people you speak of? We need names, details. Every last one. ;3

What you quoted:

All of those takes on both sides are opinions.

Sad, man. Just sad. Also, here's some polling for you

https://www.reddit.com/r/ffxiv/comme...avorite_scion/

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards...eborn/77792946

The first is from last year. The second is from three years ago. Y'shtola ranks #1 among the Scions in both. Note also that both polls put the few dozen unique posters on this forum to shame in terms of numbers.

More recent Japanese-specific polls rank Y'shtola lower, but show a huge fanbase for Venat. They also feature thousands of respondents, and rank EW as their favorite expansion (I can link those, too, if you like).

See, here's the difference. People pointing out that EW and the Scions are popular have a huge mountain of evidence to draw from supporting how many people really feel that way. People claiming "many" whatever in disagreement have nothing real to cite. The best we see is someone citing the one thread on here, ignoring that it's the same people posting over and over again and ignoring that a considerable portion of those posts are people praising the game and the Scions.