if exploits are allowed then people expect other to exploit to keep up with gear. And people who want to play legit (most people) fall behind and don't get to experience as much of the game, while those who cheat prosper.

For example in this game a lot of people i know want to do fishing, but see no point in it because it is so heavily botted that it will never be profitable.

Allowing exploits is just generally a bad idea. I personally don't care however.