Parsing unfair but okay?

[ShaneDawn]

I just cleared p1s with a dark knight in 0%... So sub 30 doesn't matter. As long as total DPS checks out.

In the end I have hit enrage more due to people not doing mechanics than DPS issues.

Someone always has to parse 0% in a given fight, that does not mean you should dismiss logs in your recruitment process. Try filling your party with nothing but resident grey loggers and see how well that goes. You will never clear the doorboss of P4S like that even if mechanics are performed correctly. At the very least not until the group outgears the content by a huge margin.

Sub-30 is a pretty arbitrary number to give, but nothing wrong with having any form of a standard in your recruitment.