So you're telling me..

[Kolsykol]

What are the standards you are going by to sat anything is “objectively” more powerful? You like to throw that word around as if it makes you right. What is to say that, objectively, Reaper isn’t fine tuned and everyone else is underperforming?

Oh, and AC isn’t OP, nor is reaper crushing anything.

People have already posted the stats over and over again and explained them.
The damage difference between a low and high skill player is significantly smaller than it is on pretty much any other dps, they're top dps, they have top utility both damage + one of the strongest healing skills in the game.
It's not the strongest if you only look at the skills in a vacuum, but in practice it absolutely is one of the strongest healing skills and this is on again a top dps with damage utility and the easiest to perform on.

I say objectively because any reasonable person with experience with Reaper and other dps and who have actually looked at the logs and know how these skills are used in practice and how efficent they are would agree to this.

Second Wind heals for shit, 500 potency or not. So, comparing it to that isn’t helping your case.

Second Wind has a 120 sec cd and isn't AoE and Reaper still have it and you can combine AC with Second Wind which only makes AC even stronger for everyone who gets it.