So you're telling me..

[Kazimere]

am I going to complain about a 30 second cooldown that has the same potency as healer spells and is able to out heal 2 of the 4 tanks while some melee jobs have nothing while also doing less dmg and reapers say there is nothing wrong with it?
that's a big thinking emoji

Sounds like a personal problem.

[ZiraZ]

I’m not arguing that it’s definitely more forgiving. That much is clear. I guess some consider that easier. Personally, I don’t. Then again, I don’t find any of the melee particularly challenging, but that is subjective.

I don't think he's talking about hard vs easy, it's about ease of performance.
Someone can go on their reaper clear EX1 for example 10 times and then do the same on their Ninja/DRG/SAM/whatever and the results will show his performance was way more consistent on the Reaper because basically nothing can really go wrong playing a reaper other than dying.
So if the reaper is so very easily autopiloted then there needs to be a cost for that just like how Range Physical can perform their entire rotation on the move, this is a real cost SE has in effect for range physical jobs just like how utility has a cost.

Sounds like a personal problem.

Reaper hidden trait: Enhanced Bias.