I'd love to see a Brawlers Guild in FF14

[Thaciscokidd]

Hard pass.

That's the kind of BS that costs other content that makes FFXIV unique and actually fun, and entirely takes away from Final Fantasy's legacy. WoW's already got that crap. Go there.

But its kinda already here with the Blue mages Masked Carnivale. It wouldn't be that hard to make something for the non limited jobs.

They could use and already lore established place like the Bloodsands and attach a story to boot. With mutiple characters attached to it I'm seriously surprised there isn't something like that isn't already in the game.

[Miles064]

It happened, I saw it happen, and yes, id rather not see FF 14 adopt the model and features that were part of WOWs utter failure. I played WOW for nine years, and have had plenty of time to see and analyse what worked..and what FAILED.

Boogeyman? No. When you see firsthand how and why WOW failed over and over and over again, it follows that one would want to avoid making the same mistakes elsewhere.

If you say so i guess. You just not liking WoW doesnt mean it failed seeing as it still seems to be doing just fine. Wow taking inspiration from deep dungeons got it torghast which is some of the most fun ive had in that game in a while. If SE could take some things from blizz and put that FF spin to it I think it would turn out pretty great.

[VelKallor]

If you say so i guess. You just not liking WoW doesnt mean it failed seeing as it still seems to be doing just fine.

Um...doing fine? No. I take it you havent been keeping up on current events....

Wow taking inspiration from deep dungeons got it torghast which is some of the most fun ive had in that game in a while. If SE could take some things from blizz and put that FF spin to it I think it would turn out pretty great.

They took PoTD and HoH, turned it into MANDATORY content, and has been one of the most contentious, most complained about and one of the worst failures of Shadowlands.

From the WOW forums

No, because they locked legendaries behind it. Well knowing that not everybody would be happy with the repetitive nature of it. That and it should’ve been entirely optional, but optional content just isn’t a thing in WoW apparently.

PoTD and HoH are OPTIONAL, not part of a daily list of chores.

it was fun the first 3 times. Then it was just another chore to check off the list

[Miles064]

Um...doing fine? No. I take it you havent been keeping up on current events....



They took PoTD and HoH, turned it into MANDATORY content, and has been one of the most contentious, most complained about and one of the worst failures of Shadowlands.

From the WOW forums



PoTD and HoH are OPTIONAL, not part of a daily list of chores.

So don't make it mandatory? Tying soul ash and soul cinders to it was kinda lame but lucky for me I enjoyed running it anyway so I was swimming in the stuff. Never mind you only had to do it once per week and the big burst came from the lower floors so it was no different than running expert for tomes. One the other hand PotD and HoH are just kinda lame and are just used for solo high floor runs and lvling. Or are we assuming the forums in wow speaks for the majority even though FF's does not? Do you not think SE could address your issues with it by making it themselves?

[Roda]

Something like that would be a neat addition for the Gold Saucer.

Doesn't need to be gold saucer, Ul'dah has a coliseum that's begging to be used!

[Maxilor]

Hard pass.

That's the kind of BS that costs other content that makes FFXIV unique and actually fun, and entirely takes away from Final Fantasy's legacy. WoW's already got that crap. Go there.

Adding one thing does not have to take away from the other.

Also yes, 'WoW Bad' we get it already.

[Klaleara]

So don't make it mandatory? Tying soul ash and soul cinders to it was kinda lame but lucky for me I enjoyed running it anyway so I was swimming in the stuff. Never mind you only had to do it once per week and the big burst came from the lower floors so it was no different than running expert for tomes. One the other hand PotD and HoH are just kinda lame and are just used for solo high floor runs and lvling. Or are we assuming the forums in wow speaks for the majority even though FF's does not? Do you not think SE could address your issues with it by making it themselves?

Not sure why someone would even say it shouldn't be in FF14 because its Mandatory in WoW. Never said I wanted a copy/paste lol.

One of the great things about FF14, is that they seem to avoid the mandatory aspect that WoW has, and mah lawd is it a breath of fresh air. I love playing content FOR FUN, instead of making it a job.