[SPOILERS] What was your choice in the quest 'Returning Home?'

[NegativeS]

When it gave the choice, I expected Krile to be behind the door, upset that we didn't recognize her knocking. But I did choose Estinien first, because he was definitely the one I wanted to see behind that door. Estinien is the best.

When I realized that the choice actually affected who you had a conversation with, I then watched all of them in The Unending Journey, in descending order of who I would have liked to be behind the door... Estinien, then Y'shtola, then G'raha Tia, then Alphinaud, then Alisaie, then finally Thancred. Sorry, Thancred. You're too lone-wolf for me to want to relate to, and not endearingly traumatized like Estinien. G'raha Tia's was probably my favorite, though he did look like a crack fiend before I opened the door.
yes i know he was just nervous

Honestly, seeing all the Scions confide in me like that warmed my heart. The writing for Endwalker is phenomenal so far.

But enough gushing.

Who did you pick your first time through the cutscene?

[Lexis]

G'Raha Tia was my personal pick for that one. He's the one I picture as my WoL's most intimate friend and their interraction was just perfect.

I did think about checking the other options out at the inn afterwards but decided against it as I felt it would diminish the moment. I'll pick a different character when I get an alt there but considering said alt is still in arr, it's gonna be a while.

[Roda]

Thancred. Started in Ul'dah, and wanted to tell my boy to PUT DOWN ALL THOSE DAMN DEATHFLAGS HE'S BEEN HOLDING

[AziraSyuren]

I chose G'raha Tia because I felt like he was actually the most likely person to come visit us at that hour.

[Kozh]

Thancred. My favorite scion.

He and estinien are the "talk less and will get the job done" type, which I prefer than the annoying g'raha.

Second option is alphinaud because he's my WoL little brother.

[Phaty]

I chose Alisaie cuz she's bae

[Nekaru_Infitima]

G'raha, I actually assumed he was the one knocking.

[Ayer2015]

I didn't know who to choose at first, but ended up picking Y'shtola.

[Nightingaile]

Y'shtola... mostly because I guessed that it determined who was actually at the door... and because she never visits me and I want to be her romantic interest Q.Q. In any case we had a nice platonic chat. It was alright. In hindsight I would have picked G'raha, Estinien, Urianger, or Alphinaud.

[Rayne6665]

My boi Alphinaud