Shadowbringers was better. The process of jumping from dark story telling to light hearted bs back to dark story telling got stale. After every zone I had to chill with the scions whom I was hoping were going to be killed off earlier in the plot. Most zones felt overly drawn out. And Tataru still lives...I hate tataru. The plot had its high points that stood out but most were wtf moments or shocking twists. I would say its better than SB and maybe on par with HW.