Simian Thrash should get some boost.

[Kazimir]

So you are saying you punching something with your fists, should do more damage than someone using a giant spear and destroying an enemy. I still have issues with monk multi-hit Weapon skills doing more than Rampage or Decimation in FF11. I would highly disagree that a punch attack should ever do more than a spear attack. But I wouldn't be against the idea of maybe after using Simian Thrash, that maybe the pugilist's Stamina usage is decreased by 1/2 for 15 seconds after using it.

*Edited for spelling and capitalization errors*

So because a PUG uses their fists you think they shouldn't do as much DPS as other classes, which would make them a rather worthless class? This is the dumbest thing I've read in the last 5 minutes.

@OP Simian Thrash is weak because it's technically supposed to be used to hold hate. It has high enmity generation. Too bad were rather pointless tanks as long as GLA are around.

I'd suggest removing the high enmity, getting rid of the pre-req to use it, and increase the dmg so we can actually be the DPS we'll be used as and not the semi-tank we were apparently supposed to be.