Audio popping issue

[Elliah-Seraheart]

Well, I can show you a video if you want. There's is an absolute 100% 1:1 correlation with zero delay whatsoever when I change that setting. You can IMMEDIATELY see it cause the sound issues or resolve it (as long as it's not a big battle), in real time, without hurting the FPS much until you go too low. It disproportionately affects the audio.

Again, I can record a video and show it, it's not a guess or theory. It affects it instantaneously and I've been switching back and forth as I play to have less broken sound in dungeons and trials, and going back while waiting in queues, so I don't have excess heat and fan noise. The moment I click it, the sound instantly changes, and the FPS remains good either way.

Edit: Also, just to add more detail, the CPU usage doesn't seem to ever go too far past 50% in any case anyways, according to windows task manager.

Sadly - I can claim the exact opposite. There are people who CAN see a clear correlation and there are people who absolutely cannot claim the same. But this is precisely why I'm led to believe that CPU spikes are generally not the cause of this. It's always hard to differentiate causation, correlation and synchronicities. Hell, there may even be multiple different causes for the same issue. It's not that straight forward. Ask any doctor, or technician. I'd still encourage you to share any footage you got - because it may help devs diagnose issues, may help you and everyone suffering from the same causes.

On another note - I didn't play for a few days, and it randomly got MUCH better. I really only get it in Inns and some parts of towns now. In combat I'm almost free of issues. I may get half a second of it every 5 minutes or so. It's been like this for 2 days now. I didn't change a thing. On the contrary - I've been taxing my CPU more, with Adobe Programs in the background while playing. I also turned my miner back on.

I hope your issues get better as well - one way or another.

[Yin]

It is interesting to see, that in DE there are not so many complaints, posts and threads about this issue, but here in EN forums. I was so "glad" somehow to see this thread, because I (and my husband) seemed to be the only ones with THIS issue.

Since Day One of Endwalker I cannot play anymore, because I do not want to ruin my Game Experience and I do not want to mute everything.

I have not even started the Main Story, I do not know how all the content is, I only took Sage and Reaper and am leveling them a bit.

I noticed the issue with the very first (Reaper Job) Quests, and because the sound is so annoying and disturbing I never continued any Quest at all.

I tried everything suggested here and really nothing helped

[Cithaerias_pyropina]

Bumping this so it doesn't get lost and also adding what's been happening to me.

Noticed a couple things;

All audio (and only in this game as everything outside of the game functions normally); music, SFX, system sounds, ambient sounds, voices and performance, stutters depending on the camera angle, or my character's location in relation to what I'm attacking or whoever else is doing something.

Sometimes the audio stutters depending on where my character is physically located. Example; friend's striking dummy in the goblet. He has a striking dummy directly facing a wall and I'm keeping the camera position facing the wall. When I attack the dummy from behind the sounds stutter. When I attack from its left flank the sounds stutter. When I attack the dummy from its right flank the sounds never stutter. When I attack from the front the sounds never stutter. This also occurs in dungeons and I have to physically move to certain areas around my party's targets to not have the audio stutter.

I will have all audio but music muted and in certain zones and during certain boss encounters in dungeons, all Haukke Manor bosses and all Stone Vigil bosses for example, the music will stutter within 10 seconds of loading in the zone or within 10 seconds of the fight occuring. Unmuting SFX seems to make the music stop stuttering but as soon as I mute SFX the music will start stuttering again. The stuttering also stops occurring when I move my character to certain places around the target. Strange thing is if I have everything but SFX muted the SFX never stutters as often as music does in certain places.

The stuttering is drastically exacerbated if my Listening Position is any less than 100.

[Tessmarin]

Bumping this so it doesn't get lost and also adding what's been happening to me.

Noticed a couple things;

All audio (and only in this game as everything outside of the game functions normally); music, SFX, system sounds, ambient sounds, voices and performance, stutters depending on the camera angle, or my character's location in relation to what I'm attacking or whoever else is doing something.

Sometimes the audio stutters depending on where my character is physically located. Example; friend's striking dummy in the goblet. He has a striking dummy directly facing a wall and I'm keeping the camera position facing the wall. When I attack the dummy from behind the sounds stutter. When I attack from its left flank the sounds stutter. When I attack the dummy from its right flank the sounds never stutter. When I attack from the front the sounds never stutter. This also occurs in dungeons and I have to physically move to certain areas around my party's targets to not have the audio stutter.

I will have all audio but music muted and in certain zones and during certain boss encounters in dungeons, all Haukke Manor bosses and all Stone Vigil bosses for example, the music will stutter within 10 seconds of loading in the zone or within 10 seconds of the fight occuring. Unmuting SFX seems to make the music stop stuttering but as soon as I mute SFX the music will start stuttering again. The stuttering also stops occurring when I move my character to certain places around the target. Strange thing is if I have everything but SFX muted the SFX never stutters as often as music does in certain places.

The stuttering is drastically exacerbated if my Listening Position is any less than 100.

Yeah someone a while back did a video on how it seems to be positional and bounces more off of objects. If I position my camera above it seems to reduce as well.

One interesting thing happened a few days ago for me - the sound issues in game became extremely bad but when I tabbed out they migrated into my entire machine even when just clicking the sound volume tester on the task bar. The static was so bad I had to reboot my entire machine and go back to the queue. This happens occasionally but if it helps with troubleshooting I thought it would be good to make sure I dropped that info here. This issue is super intermittent some dungeons I am fine others are borderline unbearable but there is always some level of static, stuttering and distortion occurring. Mt Gulg so far has been the absolute worst of them all.

[AeroXaia]

So what is it you are suggesting? Go into power options and down throttle the cpu manually? I will try and see if it works for me.

EDIT: Throttling the CPU down made no appreciable difference for me, in fact the lower I throttled it the worse my issue got.

Yeah, that's what I'm saying, lowering it makes it worse. I don't have a solution, I'm just trying to get to the root of the issue so it can be fixed.

Sadly - I can claim the exact opposite. There are people who CAN see a clear correlation and there are people who absolutely cannot claim the same. But this is precisely why I'm led to believe that CPU spikes are generally not the cause of this. It's always hard to differentiate causation, correlation and synchronicities. Hell, there may even be multiple different causes for the same issue. It's not that straight forward. Ask any doctor, or technician. I'd still encourage you to share any footage you got - because it may help devs diagnose issues, may help you and everyone suffering from the same causes.

On another note - I didn't play for a few days, and it randomly got MUCH better. I really only get it in Inns and some parts of towns now. In combat I'm almost free of issues. I may get half a second of it every 5 minutes or so. It's been like this for 2 days now. I didn't change a thing. On the contrary - I've been taxing my CPU more, with Adobe Programs in the background while playing. I also turned my miner back on.

I hope your issues get better as well - one way or another.

I'm just telling my experience and what I've found, hoping to get closer to the cause/solution. Are you afraid if CPU is part of it, it won't get fixed? It's affecting a lot of people that it wasn't before, I doubt they would just say "nope, just get a better CPU" when they can't even afford servers with all the congestion.

If you lower that setting enough and it has no effect, I'd be extremely surprised. Lowering the maximum CPU allowed should throttle the CPU no matter what, since you're setting the upper bounds of the range. With less CPU, like you said, it should come up with all kinds of issues, but again I'd be surprised if you didn't also run into sound issues before other issues, if you go down in 10% steps for example.

[GorthRedsteel]

I have just finished the patch content of base game and I feel great regret. I have forced myself to play as I had already wasted a week waiting for the fix. Sadly, still no word from SE. It was such a disaster watching those great cutscenes with stutter, constant static noise, and slowed down voice acting that would cut before the end of each dialog. It pains me that such crucial experience and part of the story got destroyed by the issue. I really don't know what to do now. I badly wanna continue with HW but if it's gonna be fucked by the same crap then what's the point. Hard to immerse yourself if audio keeps trying to damage your eardrums lol.
Pity. :/

[Aylin]

I have been having this issue since Early Access opened. Any time I am in battle (and thankfully, only in battle) the sounds cracks, stutters, pops, and is generally painful to even listen to at this point.
I have found that by moving my mouse around and changing my angle, it will improve from some angles, but usually it's an angle that makes it impossible to play effectively (can't do a trial if you have to have your camera pointed away from the fight so the sound doesn't make me want to scream anymore).
I have a sneaky suspicion it's something to do with new the sound settings, but I'm no professional so don't quote me on that- kind of ironic though that this fancy new setting is added, and all of a sudden, all these people- myself included- are having sound problems when there were none before.
Please please fix this soon. I *want* to listen to this game, not feel like I have to turn the sound off completely to even try to be a productive member of a group.

[PinkBismuth]

Just posting a reply here since I'm having the same issue as well and none of the fixes mentioned by others has worked so far. The only thing I have been able to do so far to help has been to mute the Master Volume in the settings so that when I enter combat or heavily populated areas I don't start stuttering. I even tried to mute everything except for the system sounds so that I would still be able to hear the alarms for timed gathering nodes and eventually if I was in a dungeon when the alarm pinged it would suddenly begin stuttering again.

The most annoying part is seeing everyone talk about how good and great and wonderful and amazing the music is in all the new zones and I can't even have the audio for an alarm timer enabled because it'll start making things wonky. It's not like we can realistically stay out of combat either, unless you're someone who spends hours on end doing emotes to other people in town. Even though I'm not some kind of audiophile who is necessarily missing out on a lot from not hearing the BGM, having to experience combat with no sound really has made me realize how much the combat audio helps my gameplay. I have a new found respect for any deaf gamers out there. Although, it is nice being able to do a hunt train without hearing that 1 annoying squealing female mi'qote that always seems to end up right behind me no matter what server I'm on.

[minopoki]

I still think that if they just gave us an option to enable the old sound driver from pre 6.0, this problem would be solved.
Sure it requires a client update, but I don't see why it would have to wait until Jan. 21st.

[AluneTempest]

my fear is they will not fix this problem in the next patch, because i have not seen them specify the problem that we are having.