Hmm... interesting.
Hm, good point. But even if she can't recognize the color of your soul like Emet and Hyth, why doesn't she at least recognize who you are in Elpis based on your physical appearance? She claims that you've never met before when you first encounter her on the island. Emet at least seems to know what you look like, based on his comments when you first meet him. Or is that because everyone wears masks?