Quote Originally Posted by SafeOnBlock View Post
Since when has square given us what we want? Also I am a fan, I know a bunch of fans of the game that like the idea which is what spawned this post to begin with. There are a total of 10 people posting in this forum with opinions. Some agreed some disagreed. Some people dont even know what they want, and others wouldnt know a good idea if it hit them in the ars.

I get that not everyone is gunna like the idea. I have actually heard some decent reasons. Hell I know I wouldnt be 100% sure I would want a FFVII remake (one of my favorite games of all time) Because there are certain nuances that cant be portrayed the way they were supposed to in the original. Yet there comes a time when you take the bad with the good and if the good outweighs the bad then it may be worth considering.
This is a pretty good example...the game we're playing now. SE does a pretty good job at trying to deliver to its fanbase. I think they deserve more credit than they are given. In any case, my point is that this thread makes it pretty clear the majority is just not on your side of the fence. It would be wiser to just scrap the idea, or modify the idea, or approach a similar idea from a different angle, rather than force ppl to give you valid reasons why they dont like it. The only thing that matters is that they don't. Valid reasons are irrelevant, all valid reasons do is salvage the pride of the person that came up with the idea. I'm telling you to drop the pride and move on to a different idea. You seem to be creative enough, and adventurous enough, there's no need to get too attached to one proposition. You've tested the waters, the reception isn't exactly positive, so try something else. Put on your thinking cap and go at it again. There's more than one way to skin a cat after all, and maybe aspects of your idea could work in a different form? Just drop it as it is now and come back with a vengeance.