"Everyone's so open and friendly" is a lie

[linayar]

It is a negative regardless of how you try to spin it, because it's an otherwise completely pointless statement. I also play League of Legends. Am I to be referred to as a "LoL player" in FF14, despite me playing FF14 at the time and LoL not coming up as a subject of discussion?

That depends on the person using the label.

But I'll let you explain in what scenario, ever, this could be perceived as positive. Enlighten me.

Why should I when I just said it's a neutral label?

people often coming up with excuses as to why our loving community could never send death threats or dox people and it could just totally be people who were banned.

It's pointless to try to excuse those who would send death threats as they would do it under cover of anonymity.

Thus, it's also pointless to complain to the wider community about them as if there's anything we can do about it.

The only thing we can be sure of is that, if they try to do it in game, they would be banned, if they're not already.

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

That depends on the person using the label.

Why should I when I just said it's a neutral label?

It's pointless to try to excuse those who would send death threats as they would do it under cover of anonymity.

Thus, it's also pointless to complain to the wider community about them as if there's anything we can do about it.

The only thing we can be sure of is that, if they try to do it in game, they would be banned, if they're not already.

Alas, they love to bring up the death threats and doxxing, like we all cheered them for doing it or something. Pretty much everyone I saw condemned them tho. Yet apparently because it happened every single person who ever played the game bears responsibility.

[linayar]

Alas, they love to bring up the death threats and doxxing, like we all cheered them for doing it or something. Pretty much everyone I saw condemned them tho. Yet apparently because it happened every single person who ever played the game bears responsibility.

It's a low hanging fruit, but it only works against those who think that everyone who plays FFXIV is now a perfect member of the community. I think most people can understand that people are still flawed beings and leave it at that. They can still say this community is good or nice or great or the best based on their subjective values and experiences even when presented with negative actions being done in the name of FFXIV.

[Michieltjuhh]

That depends on the person using the label.

Why should I when I just said it's a neutral label?

So it's a neutral label that has no use or value and makes people shrug at why you used it at best and a negative one in any other scenario? I think they did something like that in the Third Reich, where it started off as relatively harmless label - albeit pointless, people are people - and ended up.. well we know how that evolved. Now, of course, this is an extreme that won't happen, but that doesn't mean it's not going to be used negatively, even against people that don't even come from WoW - just as a general term to imply something negative. It already is.

There are labels that have (perceived) value, such as "sprout" - new player, or "mentor" - experienced player. This isn't one of them.