

Yeah so far I'm in agreement there. But I've yet to do the MSQ so I don't know if better shows up after 80. The ones I have seen thus far all look too 'magitech' and not enough 'scythe'. Given the class lore that makes sense - but it's not the style I like.
Striving for perfection is the path to one's downfall. 'Tis the paradox of the immaculate carrot. | Jah Bless. One God, One Aim, and One Destiny - Marcus Garvey.
Until the philosophy which holds one race superior and another inferior is finally and permanently discredited and abandoned, everywhere is war - Ras Tafari.
My reaper is level 85 atm, it plays a LOT better once I got it to 80. The shroud really livens it up, it is by far imo the easiest melee. You get a lot of freedom. The only thing you need to worry about is keeping your debuff up and not capping same as most things except your only positionals you pretty much will always have true north for when u cannot hit em.
There is virtually no ogcd management at all.. 2 buttons to push and your shroud is all gcds so it really is easy peasy. Really fun, love the aesthetic it makes my DRK heart happy.

I definitely love the Reaper. My only issue with it, at the moment, is how much it annoys me that Shroud Gauge and Enshroud are Lv80, as that makes half the game-play identity of the Reaper be locked behind post-ShadowBringers... Reaper still plays well at Lv70-79, but it feels iffy Lv60-69 and not at all that good at Lv51-59 HeavensWard levels...
like.. true, Reaper does function, and play well enough, at Lv70 and Lv60... but, it does not feel well.
I just mean how it feels to play, as I slowly strip away more and more of its identity, as I drop down in levels and into older content... some of the jobs feel like they lose their identity less at Lv70 and Lv60, than what Reaper does, while half its identity locked at Lv80 drives me up a wall for a personal reason.
but those little pet peeves of mine aside, I think that Reaper feels good and I definitely like it.
[...]A much better thing to do with a large amount of actions, too many for a player to use all of the actions, is to create in-class diversity. ...hieh.. my disappointment finds it mind-blowing stupid that FFXIV never did this, and has always done that delete actions nonsense, instead.[...] ------------ [...]"I want you to lower me down into my coffin... so that you can.. let. me. down.. one. last. time." - 6.0 Dark Knight[...]
[...]"...you want to know.. why I chose to abandon the abyss for the void? ...It is simple. That power of darkness did fail me, so I chose to embrace a new power of the darkness...." - Anahlise, a Reaper[...]
My only thing I could wish be better for reaper is if Soulsow/Harvest Moon rewarded some gauge when used. It's a high potency but wish it gave just the usual gain on ability. Didn't read the forum if anybody else mentioned, but I absolutely love this class. This is literally my only thing I dislike about the class
I think Harvest Moon should have some synergy with Crest, Harpe or Circle. Either allowing the use of Immortal Sacrifices for free HMs(using 1 stack or more) before expending on Harvest, If crest breaks you proc Harvest Moon and get the Regen or have Harpe give a percentage to proc Harvest Moon akin to Firestarter procs from BLM.
Soulsow/Harvest Moon is the only skill I don't like at all. Which is a shame since the charge animation badass.




I think Harvest Moon is fine the way it is. There's too much emphasis in the FFXIV community on having every button press do something useful in every single situation. This is a niche optimization tool. You probably won't be punished too hard for not knowing how to use it, but some will figure out a way to squeeze out extra dps with it by recharging during mechanics heavy intermissions. This job is closest thing to perfection that they've ever released, and I'm very worried that some well minding buffoons will destroy it by making some completely unwanted suggestions that will inevitably be taken up by a job development/balance team that is completely incapable from filtering out out good recommendations from bad. Lightning does not strike twice.
'Uh, duh gap closah is hard. What is keybind?'
'Okay, let's remove Ingress/Egress and give Reaper Plunge instead on two charges, with a cooldown reduction trait on Harpe.'
Please, if you think that you have a helpful recommendation for Reaper, kindly do us all a favor and suggest it to Monk instead for their upcoming fortieth rework. Or alternatively, let them know what an obvious missed story opportunity that they had in the job quests in not letting you banter with your symbiote Voidsent. No, we cannot eat the fire primal. Grapes?
Honestly, all of this. The class is quite well done. I would imagine we will get a trait in future expansions allowing some sort of proc that will give us a Soulsow stack to perform Harvest Moon in combat without the charge time, but as it stands now there have been multiple times in various fights where the boss becomes untargetable, giving us time to charge it in combat.I think Harvest Moon is fine the way it is. There's too much emphasis in the FFXIV community on having every button press do something useful in every single situation. This is a niche optimization tool. You probably won't be punished too hard for not knowing how to use it, but some will figure out a way to squeeze out extra dps with it by recharging during mechanics heavy intermissions. This job is closest thing to perfection that they've ever released, and I'm very worried that some well minding buffoons will destroy it by making some completely unwanted suggestions that will inevitably be taken up by a job development/balance team that is completely incapable from filtering out out good recommendations from bad. Lightning does not strike twice.
'Uh, duh gap closah is hard. What is keybind?'
'Okay, let's remove Ingress/Egress and give Reaper Plunge instead on two charges, with a cooldown reduction trait on Harpe.'
Please, if you think that you have a helpful recommendation for Reaper, kindly do us all a favor and suggest it to Monk instead for their upcoming fortieth rework. Or alternatively, let them know what an obvious missed story opportunity that they had in the job quests in not letting you banter with your symbiote Voidsent. No, we cannot eat the fire primal. Grapes?
The only real tweak I would enjoy right *now*, would be to simply change Hellgate to last the full 15 seconds that our In/Egress is on cooldown.
I agree with all of this, Reaper is honestly one the best designed jobs so far. You have a good melee skillset, a unique gap closer that essentially becomes 2 uses if you can use it well, and while your ranged skillset isn't its main focus, it's there if you have to attack at a distance. Plus, it isn't that weak at all in potency. At the same time, it gives the job fantasy of playing as a reaper perfectly. The animation for Harpe is great too. Soulsow is great for that niche optimization in moments where you can't target the boss. It's now my go-to for a melee DPS job.I think Harvest Moon is fine the way it is. There's too much emphasis in the FFXIV community on having every button press do something useful in every single situation. This is a niche optimization tool. You probably won't be punished too hard for not knowing how to use it, but some will figure out a way to squeeze out extra dps with it by recharging during mechanics heavy intermissions. This job is closest thing to perfection that they've ever released, and I'm very worried that some well minding buffoons will destroy it by making some completely unwanted suggestions that will inevitably be taken up by a job development/balance team that is completely incapable from filtering out out good recommendations from bad. Lightning does not strike twice.
'Uh, duh gap closah is hard. What is keybind?'
'Okay, let's remove Ingress/Egress and give Reaper Plunge instead on two charges, with a cooldown reduction trait on Harpe.'
Please, if you think that you have a helpful recommendation for Reaper, kindly do us all a favor and suggest it to Monk instead for their upcoming fortieth rework. Or alternatively, let them know what an obvious missed story opportunity that they had in the job quests in not letting you banter with your symbiote Voidsent. No, we cannot eat the fire primal. Grapes?


I've finally gotten Reaper to lvl 90 and I have a few nitpicks.
1st: Soulsow / Harvest Moon. I think it has the same problems Shoha did on it's first outing and I'm not sure why the devs decided to do it again. Soulsow doesn't even charge any of your gauges. I feel like Harvest Moon could have just been an upgrade to Nightmare Scythe.
2nd: The DoT that's not a DoT. I don't mind applying it with one button but I kind of wish Infernal Slice and Nightmare Scythe kept extending it. Shadow and Whorl of Death don't grant gauge so it always feels like a waste having to constantly reapply it.
3rd: I think Ingress and Regress should be made 10s and remove the enhanced Harpe effect. Then make Harpe instant and lower it's damage or something. I'd rather be able to dash more and be able to attack while moving when I have to run out of melee range.
4th: I kind of feel like Blood Stalk should work like Gnashing Fang on GNB. Where when you use Blood Stalk it triggers the combo Gibbet > Gallaows, or Gallows > Gibbet if you prefer. This way Gluttany could just be an upgrade to Blood Stalk or Grim Swathe.
5th: I would like Communio to be instant cast but that's just me hating casts on a melee. I also wish Void Reaping and Cross Reaping became Communio with only 1 Death Gauge charge left.
All and all I think Reaper is fun, once you get to 80 anyway. I look forward to seeing how they improve it later on if they do.
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
|
|
Cookie Policy
This website uses cookies. If you do not wish us to set cookies on your device, please do not use the website. Please read the Square Enix cookies policy for more information. Your use of the website is also subject to the terms in the Square Enix website terms of use and privacy policy and by using the website you are accepting those terms. The Square Enix terms of use, privacy policy and cookies policy can also be found through links at the bottom of the page.


Reply With Quote




