Quote Originally Posted by Veloran View Post
Clearly G'raha doesn't know everything, since it happened.
This is irrelevant to the point I was making: That G'raha sees Minfilia and Ryne's shenanigans as fundamentally different from the WoL and Ardbert's.

In conjunction with calling her a reincarnation this seems quite clearcut as a rejoining.
This is a bit hard to unpack, but I interpreted Emet-Selch's words as follows:

He thought Ryne was a reincarnation of the Oracle of Light. He is surprised at how poorly she's performed under that metric. What he's just learned about her needing to awaken the true Oracle made him reexamine her, and he discovered that Minfilia's soul is actually laying dormant inside of Ryne, rather than being Ryne's soul.

In other words: He was mistaken about Ryne being a reincarnation.

As for being a rejoining, like I said... G'raha says nothing about it. He was there for Emet-Selch's breakdown of the matter. He's seen the results of Ryne's alleged rejoining. He's also seen the results of our rejoining with Ardbert. And his commentary on that matter is "well that should have been impossible". Not "I can't believe that happened twice". To me, that says he views Ryne's situation and ours as fundamentally different.

There's also the little matter of Ryne explicitly having never heard Hydaelyn's voice, despite being present for every single star shower we've witnessed on the First. This shouldn't be the case if she were Minfilia's reincarnation or a shard of the same soul, since Minfilia explicitly had the Echo.