The problem, for me, with the Sightseeing Log is that it's yet another list of commands you're following (much like searching with the Aether Compass) - rather than that you accidentally bump into a lore object - which makes it feel more forced, less open. You're not using your eyes and senses, but rather you follow (vague) directions. Also, you learn little about the world, the architecture, the history, the flora, etc.