Nah, your intent is to get a raise out of the forum people. Obvious troll thread.

I can see how the commend system can be improved, for example by making the party list linger for a bit, so you can commend the people who dropped out immediately, before you had a chance to, and by adding incentives to commending people.

Having a punishment system in place for "bad performance" is exactly what we don't need.

That's Mythic+, a system that already exists in WOW. Give it a try.