Clearing up some lore misconceptions

[TheRealQuah]

I believe that the correct answer to the "do we solo primals" is both yes and no.

Being the reincarnation of Azem, our echo allows us to summon other parts of our sundered soul, in the same way Elidibus summons heores to fight us during the heroes gauntlet. So canonically, the 3 people we fight Ifrit with in normal are 3 summoned parts of our own soul. So we aren't alone, but it's also just other parts of our soul from other shards.

Whilst we only find out about this power in 5.3, we have been using it all along since the beginning without knowing why or how. It does come across as something that was written later on to explain it, but I think it fits well.

During the Seat of Sacrifice fight, Elidibus banishes us to the aetherial and thinks he has killed us, which we see we are brought back using the crystal by an echo of Emet-Selch - in this instance he has effectively raised us to the seat of Azem thus proving that we have been a shard of Azem all along. We were effectively raised in the same way that other ascians are after they have been defeated.

[Cleretic]

I believe that the correct answer to the "do we solo primals" is both yes and no.

Being the reincarnation of Azem, our echo allows us to summon other parts of our sundered soul, in the same way Elidibus summons heores to fight us during the heroes gauntlet. So canonically, the 3 people we fight Ifrit with in normal are 3 summoned parts of our own soul. So we aren't alone, but it's also just other parts of our soul from other shards.

Whilst we only find out about this power in 5.3, we have been using it all along since the beginning without knowing why or how. It does come across as something that was written later on to explain it, but I think it fits well.

During the Seat of Sacrifice fight, Elidibus banishes us to the aetherial and thinks he has killed us, which we see we are brought back using the crystal by an echo of Emet-Selch - in this instance he has effectively raised us to the seat of Azem thus proving that we have been a shard of Azem all along. We were effectively raised in the same way that other ascians are after they have been defeated.

Well that theory deflates the whole purpose of the Dying Gasp and Seat of Sacrifice as a climax. It is no longer a Big Deal Special Climax Thing, but rather, just... the same thing you think we've been doing the entire game up until this point, just with a bit more pomp and circumstance.

[Alenore]

I believe that the correct answer to the "do we solo primals" is both yes and no.

Being the reincarnation of Azem, our echo allows us to summon other parts of our sundered soul, in the same way Elidibus summons heores to fight us during the heroes gauntlet. So canonically, the 3 people we fight Ifrit with in normal are 3 summoned parts of our own soul. So we aren't alone, but it's also just other parts of our soul from other shards.

Whilst we only find out about this power in 5.3, we have been using it all along since the beginning without knowing why or how. It does come across as something that was written later on to explain it, but I think it fits well.

During the Seat of Sacrifice fight, Elidibus banishes us to the aetherial and thinks he has killed us, which we see we are brought back using the crystal by an echo of Emet-Selch - in this instance he has effectively raised us to the seat of Azem thus proving that we have been a shard of Azem all along. We were effectively raised in the same way that other ascians are after they have been defeated.

What about instances where we were 8. We would have had to summon 7 people, which makes... 15 shards (8 of us, and 7 summoned).
So, unlikely.