Soooooooooooooooooo... Yes, there's topics like this a bit everywhere.
I'd just like to point out that the side of the community who fully enjoys MCH is mostly composed of casuals. They don't know about the many problems of the job until they face those. Most of them have no idea that Flamethrower is the lowest priority of aoes, or about the Flamethrower tick fishing.
Job action was safe but uncreative, gotta agree.

SMN really needed a rework but they sure have a bias towards caster. If you compare MCH rework and DRK rework to SMN rework, it jumps to the eyes.
SMN gets a crap ton of work each expansion and they're even reluctant to nerf the job regardless of how broken it is.

But that SMN reworks seems final and honestly feels like the MCH curse. A job designed for my grandma.