Quote Originally Posted by Karthunk View Post
I agree! Spamming a sequence of three+ buttons is when the true fun starts!
If having a one-button rotation is good, fun gameplay for healers, it should also be good, fun gameplay for casters, right? If it's okay for WHM to spend half the fight casting Glare, then it's okay for BLM to spend half the fight casting Fire. Not Fire 4, or Fire 3, just Fire; we'll cut the BLM kit all the way back to Fire and Thunder, give them one nuke, and one DoT, same as every healer. No Astral Fire/Ice to worry about, no Enochian to maintain, no Xenoglossy procs to watch, no Ley Lines to worry about positioning, just the pure unadulterated fun of a 211111111 rotation.

How many people would still play BLM at that point? Would BLM be a fun, engaging class to play?

No? Why not? After all, BLMs are just "spamming a sequence of three+ buttons." And you said that wasn't fun.