You're missing the point. ARR SMN literally had no idea of their damage. Were they worth bringing vs another BRD or even a Melee? You couldn't tell. They were flying blind in actual content especially given so much of it was multi target back then.
Pop into British Walkabout and call a few people muppets, let me know how that goes for you.
On the list, precisely, all of those things are far far more impactful on the game as a whole than the number of groups that are going to clear DSR and wave around a few shiny weapons this year. On bots being bannable, eeehhhhh I mean sure but outside of RMT spam who actually really gets banned for it? Look at Eureka bots or go right as far back as Northern Thanalan Fate bots. Are they really getting banned all the time? I don't see it, never have.
Doesn't matter if it's imperfect when it's the only readily available info sir. As for really poorly calculated? Please cite your sources on that one.
Sure, I'm in agreement that Ultimates aren't about the DPS checks, but they are still a sterner test of things than Savage even with the trend of untargetable intermissions.
If you think day one groups weren't using act you are sorely mistaken lol.
And basic feedback isn't very useful when a good portion of the data is either missing or unreadable. Simply knowing how big your crits can get isn't really the whole story.