I'm surprised that this isn't brought up, but what if you are put into a party without AoE buttons yet for their job whether a healer or DPS? That tank pulls, no one doing AOE as they don't have it yet and the tank gets upset that pulls are taking too long due to no aoe. Then the tank quits as they don't have aoe or if it is just one person without AoE they kick that person who needs the dungeon for MSQ. Is that what is wanted? I mean for the very first guildhest I think only archanist may have AoE for it other than the tank.

Another thing, any WHM below 66 doesn't have a shield for the tank. Do you kick that WHM?