The problem with jobs?

[Juzjuzz]

They do this in Bozja though.
Eureka had elemental wheel, Bozja has Magic/Physical dichotomy.

But in eureka everyone had the same elemental wheel. It didn't change how you played depending in witch jobs are here. Same with bozja, i think there is a lost action to deal with the magic/physical dmg. It's not like it changed your rotation or anything. In stormblood brds were happy with a drg (if i'm not wrong) because of piercing dmg, anything else was worse and it's not like the drg had a suddent change of playstyle.

But having to know what your opponent instead of just doing your rotation and dodging AOEs is less boring, i agree with that.

The biggest problem with making certain job "worse" against certain type ennemies is the illusion of choice. If playing drg is better than playing nin against a dragon, the only choice added is "you want better dmg or worse dmg ?" add the fact that the player doesn't like drg and it becomes frustrating. The normal response to this is "i want bigger dmg" after all.