Shell FCs are a bigger problem than we think...

[Big_Bap]

You have also not answered my question, either:

And also, do you not agree that a question phrased like "Why does it seem like JP players favor small FCs?" will not give you any response like "Yes, we disagree with <someone>" or "Yup, I'm all for deleting small FCs".
They will just explain why they like small FCs and ask why an EN player is bringing this topic to them.
But you phrased it so that it looks like the JP players all agreed with you and disagreed with this someone.
(https://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/...89#post5617889)

I answered it here:

I disagree. People here will read a thread and share whatever feelings they have about a subject. I'm sorry if that is not how it's done on your side of the forums. If you want a good example, go over to the general section and look for threads about adding female Hrothgars or male Vieras. And yes, the comments, minus yours to a certain degree, all disagree with the stance of Almagnus.

///

The thread you opened was for discussing why JP favored small FCs, not about discussing this "someone"'s plan.
It was open less than a day with only 3 page input, 3 pages until someone finally figured out what the point you were trying to make, and you take that as some kind of proof for your argument.
It's not an honest way to have an argument with someone.

Sorry if that was lost in the translation, but I talked about it in my first post:

フォーラムの英語セクションの一部のプレーヤーは、家を持っているフリーカンパニーが4人のメンバーを下回った場合、永久に削除されるべきであると信じています。

Some players in the English section of the forum believe that if a free company that owns a home falls below four members, it should be permanently removed.

And in case you missed it, I also shared a link on my 2nd post:

お返事ありがとうございます！

あなたのブラウザが翻訳をサポートしている場合、またはあなたが英語を読むことができる場合、これは議論です。

https://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/...think.../page1

Regarding the link I shared on the English forums, I don't see how disingenuous it is to share a link to another thread (where other players can translate all the content) while pointing out that nobody has said anything negative about small FCs. In fact nobody has said anything negative 2 days later...

Can't you understand that end does not justify the means?
And that's the point I'm making.

Anyway, that's all from me.
For me, you Big_Bap and Almagnus1 is going about this at the same level.
Have fun.

Thanks for your input! I'm glad the English and Japanese community dislike the idea of deleting Free Companies!

[Almagnus1]

I find it amusing that when you look at https://www.xivhousing.com/free-company-housing-2021 , Chocobo is the server that has the most FC housing (and also stays #1 depending on how you slice the data). The exact server being called out is completely arbitrary, and had there been a different one (be it a EU or NA server), I still would have called it out as that's just pointing to whatever was the lead server.

Big_Bap is just mad that I'm using their data, and that's all this "AlMaGnUs1 HaTeS jApAnEsE pLaYeRs" stupidity boils down to.