I'll echo forever: New things are better than old ones.

The Garo items? Make another set of exclusive pvp glamours and mounts. People want the legacy tattoo? Why not spruce up the subscription rewards with tattoos based on the expansion.

The line was toed with replacing the 1.0 beast tribe mounts with one slightly different, which is fine with me. Those original mounts and items have a "I was there when it happened, and this telegraphs to people" allure. Those items are few and far between in FFXIV, and the few that exist should maintain that appeal.