Benchmark trailer

[SweetPete]

Sch last expansion had broil, two Dots, miasma II for weaving and AOE, ruin 2, energy drain, and shadowflare. Don't give me that crap. We've had it before, and it was infinitely more fun.

I never said it was a mistake giving healers dps rotations. What I said was the forums were filled with dissatisfied casual players who complained that in dungeons, extremes and normal raids healers were not healing much because they were to busy with dps.

Yoshi P himself said the reason scholar lost all its dot glory was because they were leaving their co healer which was whm or Astro to do all the healing while they dps and just used faerie skills. Let’s stop acting like this is brand new. Yoshi P already spoke on this. This game caters to 80% which are casuals and that’s being generous. Healers pressing one button boring as heck? Yes but it’s the way they want it now. Complaining on the forums isn’t gonna change that. They have been very clear they want healers to focus more on healing. It is what it is. Y’all out here acting brand new like this is new news and y’all are so shocked

[Dearche]

I never said it was a mistake giving healers dps rotations. What I said was the forums were filled with dissatisfied casual players who complained that in dungeons, extremes and normal raids healers were not healing much because they were to busy with dps.

Yoshi P himself said the reason scholar lost all its dot glory was because they were leaving their co healer which was whm or Astro to do all the healing while they dps and just used faerie skills. Let’s stop acting like this is brand new. Yoshi P already spoke on this. This game caters to 80% which are casuals and that’s being generous. Healers pressing one button boring as heck? Yes but it’s the way they want it now. Complaining on the forums isn’t gonna change that. They have been very clear they want healers to focus more on healing. It is what it is. Y’all out here acting brand new like this is new news and y’all are so shocked

You know, the ironic thing about all that is that the content generally allowed SCH to get away with letting their cohealer do all the healing. I can't count how many raids where it was just better to run 5 DPS by swapping out a healer, and in the ones where that wasn't viable, SCH shined the best as it was the closest thing to an actual DPS while actually having both healing and mitigation.

[ty_taurus]

I never said it was a mistake giving healers dps rotations. What I said was the forums were filled with dissatisfied casual players who complained that in dungeons, extremes and normal raids healers were not healing much because they were to busy with dps.

Yoshi P himself said the reason scholar lost all its dot glory was because they were leaving their co healer which was whm or Astro to do all the healing while they dps and just used faerie skills. Let’s stop acting like this is brand new. Yoshi P already spoke on this. This game caters to 80% which are casuals and that’s being generous. Healers pressing one button boring as heck? Yes but it’s the way they want it now. Complaining on the forums isn’t gonna change that. They have been very clear they want healers to focus more on healing. It is what it is. Y’all out here acting brand new like this is new news and y’all are so shocked

It's not 'shocking,' it's frustrating. What's frustrating isn't their desire to want healers to focus more on healing, it's their lack of understanding on how to make that actually happening while changing everything BUT the issue. Do you want healers to heal more? The answer isn't neuter their DPS options, it's increase the need for all of these healing resources we have access to. Even if they completely abolished DPS in its entirety, it wouldn't change the fact that healers would just literally stand around and do nothing for the vast majority of content in this game. Do you want healers to heal more? Change that! I can't speak for everyone on the forums who is frustrated and angry about how the healers have fallen, but I would be willing to bet that most, if not all, would gladly welcome a more healing-heavy meta if the combat designers would actually make bosses hurt.

The problem with that is they also don't want progging new content to be exponentially more punishing and don't seem to consider adding mechanic checks that don't do damage as an option, such as damage dealt down debuffs rather than just eating a ton of damage or taking a vulnerability stack.

[Aiscence]

1) The "complicated" healers tend to...not be happy when the "simple" healer has equivalent output. Rabble rabble "we should have more output for being more complex" rabble rabble, which totally ignores the fact that, if designed this way, what you end up with isn't simple vs complex; you get novice intro class vs directly superior upgrades. I've seen this argument break out basically every time Babby's First WHM gets anywhere close to the damage output AST and SCH have. That's the rub though. If WHM has nothing going for it other than direct healing and damage, and it doesn't uniquely shine at either one of them, then it's just dead weight.

We have the same discussion in the dps forum about ranged dps where simplicity shouldn't have the same dps as others, when it s just a matter of enjoyement, if I prefer a harder class I don't wanna do more or less than the other, I just play it because it's enjoyable for me.

I never said it was a mistake giving healers dps rotations. What I said was the forums were filled with dissatisfied casual players who complained that in dungeons, extremes and normal raids healers were not healing much because they were to busy with dps.

Yoshi P himself said the reason scholar lost all its dot glory was because they were leaving their co healer which was whm or Astro to do all the healing while they dps and just used faerie skills. Let’s stop acting like this is brand new. Yoshi P already spoke on this. This game caters to 80% which are casuals and that’s being generous. Healers pressing one button boring as heck? Yes but it’s the way they want it now. Complaining on the forums isn’t gonna change that. They have been very clear they want healers to focus more on healing. It is what it is. Y’all out here acting brand new like this is new news and y’all are so shocked

I mean, when your fairy is so OP you don't have to use a single heal, or your co healer thinks that because you dont cast a spell you ain't healing and he just spam medica 2, there's not many other things I can do. Our strongest heals as sch are our ogcd because our gcds are very bad, and even when you have double their healing output with barely any overheal, they will still say "I solo healed" because they didn't see a castbar.

[Liam_Harper]

Yoshi P himself said the reason scholar lost all its dot glory was because they were leaving their co healer which was whm or Astro to do all the healing while they dps and just used faerie skills.

This is the exact situation with WHM now. If I play AST in an organized group, or I'm playing WHM with an AST friend, the AST takes the bulk of the healing. It's simple math. AST oGCD's are free and if a GCD heal is needed the WHM loses 300 potency but the AST only loses 250 and can probably proc a Horo Helios or add a Neutral sect on top. The WHM loses the party raid dps by trying to heal. Trimming their dps kit did nothing. They shouldn't be healing (unless it's movement/spare lilies or their handful of free oGCD's in their limited weave spots), it's actually bad.

This is just how ff14 is designed. It's very scripted, therefore there's a lot more mathematical calculation regarding potency and GCD efficiency. Addressing a healers dps taxes for using their toolkit compared to other healers is how you fix one healer leaving the bulk of the healing to another, not cutting their toolkit further.

The devs wanting us to heal more changes nothing in this. If you force a good player to use 50+ GCD heals in a fight, their group is still going to plan mitigation and the healer will map their heals efficiently as they learn the fight, then use the spare GCD's on damage. Even solo heal e12s kills manage to fit in 100+ casts of dps abilities.

Decent players do not prioritize dps over keeping the party alive just because they have more buttons. The bad healers who do, will do so regardless of whether they have 1 button or 5. Taking toys away from the decent players won't fix the bad ones.

[Lalatuni]

But that reveals the baffling ignorance the devs have towards healing in general. SCH doesn't look like it's casting heals cuz it's best heals are oGCDs. It's like the devs are the ignorant dps who think im not healing because they dont see me spamming medica like a tool.

[Heilstos]

Hey guys here is the offi. Job Icon from the Sage:



Maybe you want to say something

[FusionSamurai]

I never said it was a mistake giving healers dps rotations. What I said was the forums were filled with dissatisfied casual players who complained that in dungeons, extremes and normal raids healers were not healing much because they were to busy with dps.

Yoshi P himself said the reason scholar lost all its dot glory was because they were leaving their co healer which was whm or Astro to do all the healing while they dps and just used faerie skills. Let’s stop acting like this is brand new. Yoshi P already spoke on this. This game caters to 80% which are casuals and that’s being generous. Healers pressing one button boring as heck? Yes but it’s the way they want it now. Complaining on the forums isn’t gonna change that. They have been very clear they want healers to focus more on healing. It is what it is. Y’all out here acting brand new like this is new news and y’all are so shocked

You're entirely wrong. The healer changes were an effort to balance the healers, because WHM always gets left in the dumpster at the end of expansions.